What Happened to Our Education after 56 (50?) Years of Independence?


September 9, 2013

What Happened to Our Education after 56 (50?) Years of Independence?

BY RAHMAN HUSSIN@www.themalaysianinsider.com
September 09, 2013
Latest Update: September 09, 2013 10:37 am

“The whole art of teaching is only the art of awakening the natural curiosity of the mind for the purpose of satisfying it afterwards.” Anatole France.

malaysia-at-50-Malaysia-Day_129_100_100I grew up listening to many stories of how wonderful an experience of going to school in the early years following the declaration of Independence in the year 1957. Irrespective of your differences, everyone sort of bonded together during their school years.

Picnics at the park during the weekend with your schoolmates, regardless of religious and racial creed, was the norm back then. In fact, in the words of my now deceased grandmother, “It would mean the end of the world for me if I didn’t go to the park with my friends.” Such was the bond they had back then.

Politicians messing up with our education system !

Politicians messing up with our education system !

But, I aim to not discuss the strong social bonds that exist back then but instead I want to talk about the learning experience of the yesteryears. More precisely, the freedom of thought and the soul of the education experience that they went through.

As I grew up, I have this habit of talking to people and asking them what it was like learning and being educated in the early 1950’s, 60’s and 70’s. I liken this exercise as my time-travel machine, getting insights and stories from various people, since I was born in an era where some believe was the beginning of the decline of Malaysia’s intellectual progress.

In summarising all these experiences, I arrived at the conclusion (at this point I hear someone disagreeing with me on scientific grounds of my methods) that they were all learning and being educated in an environment that not only encourages questioning but also indulges curiosity and freedom of thought.

Not only was I convinced that the conclusions I made were one of the primary drivers of excellence, I believe wholeheartedly that the aforementioned environment sets these individuals up for greater success in the coming years of their lives.

A businessman I met in my secondary years in school said this to me, “Back then, we pride ourselves in asking tough questions in class and the teachers will reward us accordingly, even when we ask the most menial of questions, such as why do we have to learn in school, why can’t we just play all day?”

Swat TeamOn this one, we all can be smart

Until today, I remain regaled by stories from the glory days of yesteryears. I went through a different learning experience altogether compared with the uncles and aunties that I hear stories from. I, like most of my peers today, went through the daily Sekolah Kebangsaan and Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan in our bid to realise our dreams.

I started my schooling years believing in the fact that this was the place where all my questions will be answered, a place where I could begin the long and arduous journey of realising my dreams and achieving my full potential, after all at the back of my first exercise book; there it was the National Education Philosophy that reads:

“Pendidikan di Malaysia adalah satu usaha berterusan ke arah lebih memperkembangkan potensi individu secara menyeluruh dan bersepadu untuk melahirkan insan yang seimbang dan harmonis dari segi intelek, rohani, emosi dan jasmani berdasarkan kepatuhan dan kepercayaan kepada Tuhan. Usaha ini adalah bertujuan untuk melahirkan warganegara Malaysia yang berilmu pengetahuan, berketrampilan, berakhlak mulia, bertanggungjawab dan berkeupayaan mencapai kesejahteraan diri serta memberikan sumbangan terhadap keharmonian dan kemakmuran keluarga, masyarakat dan Negara.”

mahathir baruAsk Him Coz he should know

Surely, an important piece to realise, if not the fundamental guidelines of this philosophy is to promote and nurture the sense of curiosity. In addition, an environment that supports curiosity and allow for questions to be asked goes a long way in creating critical-thinking among students, who undoubtedly will be an important asset to this country.

Boy, was I in for a rude awakening. At the age of 10, I was made to sit outside the classroom as a result of me asking the teacher how does scolding students in public help achieve the National Education Philosophy. Curiosity wasn’t a welcome guest when I went through school, and today it is still not welcomed in classroom.

Why are we doing this to ourselves and, more importantly, to the future generation of my beloved nation?

Deaf EarsThat’s What we Have become!

Fifty years on since the inception of Malaysia, curiosity has gone from a celebrated trait to a trait no one cares about. Let us change this Malaysia. We can start by encouraging and allowing our kids to ask questions and not punish them for doing so.For a better Malaysia. – September 9, 2013.

* Rahman Hussin runs Akademi Belia.

36 thoughts on “What Happened to Our Education after 56 (50?) Years of Independence?

  1. Bean, can you answer that question. We need to chutzpah (a hebrew word) first, not ampu bodek. I have grown stupid after living in this country as an adult for the last 56 years. For this I am eternally grateful to our dear Leader, Tun Dr. Mahathir Mohamad. He made sure that my stupidity stays with me for a while yet. I am not a Melayu mudah lupa, but a Melayu bodoh. Bodoh is bliss. That chim is me. –Din Merican

  2. This is one big bullshit: “Pendidikan di Malaysia adalah satu usaha berterusan ke arah lebih memperkembangkan potensi individu secara menyeluruh dan bersepadu untuk melahirkan insan yang seimbang dan harmonis dari segi intelek, rohani, emosi dan jasmani berdasarkan kepatuhan dan kepercayaan kepada Tuhan. Usaha ini adalah bertujuan untuk melahirkan warganegara Malaysia yang berilmu pengetahuan, berketrampilan, berakhlak mulia, bertanggungjawab dan berkeupayaan mencapai kesejahteraan diri serta memberikan sumbangan terhadap keharmonian dan kemakmuran keluarga, masyarakat dan Negara.” Sounds good. So why are we stupid, Dato DM?

  3. Din.
    TS Mahayuddin salepas melancarkan education blueprint berkata ia nya akan berupaya melahirkan world class leader.

    Bullshit.PM Najib dan Mahayuddn maseh mahu menggunakan bahasa Melayu untok belajar sain dan mathematic.

    Kedua.Bleeprint ini sudah dilaksanakan oleh Singapora 50 tahun dahulu salepas ia keluar dari Malaysia.Satu keputusan yang baik di buat oleh LKY.jika tidak singaporean akan jadi bodoh macam orang Malaysia.

  4. No, Deano the Beano, it takes a smart man to say he is stupid. The ‘bodoh sombong’ among us will never know the difference.

  5. I was one of the early product of the sekolah kebangsaan and sekolah menengah kebangsaan. I can relate to Rahman’s experience about being punished for asking the tough questions but there were also times when my teachers actually took the tough questions head on and talk to the entire class about these. As a kid, I always came out of these discussions energised and ready for more. I believe my class mates too.

    On reflection, those teachers who taught me, were the remnants of the good ol’ days. The Malay teachers spoke immaculate English, even though they taught subjects in Bahasa Malaysia. In Form 1, we had a Chinese teacher who taught us Bahasa Malaysia and he was good. When I left school after 13 years of formal studies, these teachers would have retired or approaching retirement age. It’s a shame that my juniors would not have the full benefits of their counsel.

    Again on reflection, around the time I finished Form 6, the rot in the school system was starting to show in the more junior classes.

    National education blueprint or not, I owe it to my children to give them the education they deserve, be it in Malaysia or elsewhere. Not what a know-nothing education minister says. His children are probably educated somewhere else, not in Malaysia.

  6. I like that picture of the Old Goat chastising the Malays. He seems to be saying, “Pakai la otak !”

    But one thing has not changed. A Malay boy when asked “What do you want to be when you grow up?” The answer is still “I want to be a policeman”. Except the reason for wanting to aspire to be a policeman has changed. Today, he wants to get rich quick, be feared rather than be respected, As for that female member of PDRM’s Swat Team (pictured above) she wants to go ‘tembak’ somebody. Because she can.

  7. A good student in our public univ these days will still shine in their career against returnees from abroad. This is because with time on their hands while at univ, they parallel their development onto something else instead of procrastinating against their lesser colleagues. That way they develop their profile to showcase when they apply for foreign graduate scholarship. Matter of how students fulfill their time productively and how parents exemplified. Very few child is born dumb, just that the system doesn’t motivate their learning so with parent’s’ exemplification, the child adds on new dimension in knowledge acquisition and in the end develops uncommon wisdom.

  8. I remembered the earlier times when the old goat got fedup with some malay students not going the direction he wanted. He gave them several fatherly pep talks. There was some effect but insignificant because his pep talk didn’t closely monitored if the infrastructure was efficient to achieve his expected effectiveness. He expected too much too soon. He thought people could be like him. When that happens to students, the ‘switch’ off. What could be more effective is to multi-tier incentivation. He must have thought students at large can be motivated the way he brought up his kids or the way his brother in law did.

    There was a story that Tun Ismail Ali went to Subang airport to receive his son home. He had not met his father’s high expectation. On meeting his son, he gave his some unpleasant moments and some money to take taxi home himself. The only people who got to climb over his head are his grandchildren.
    _________
    Matthew,
    Tun Ismail Ali was tough on everyone who worked for him. But he left his spirit in some of us. I had a love hate relationship with him. But I admired him a lot, especially his use of English.He recommended that I read William Somerset Maugham’s short stories and novels. He introduced me to Maugham’s Of Human Bondage. After that, I read everything Maugham wrote. He also said I should read (and I did with a lot of effort) An Idealist View of Life by S. Radhakrishnan. In that book,Radhakrishnan explores aspects of the modern intellectual debate on science vis-à-vis religion and the vain attempts to find a substitute for religion. He discusses, drawing upon the traditions of East and West, the nature and validity of religious experience. Finally, he creates a fine vision of man’s evolution and the emergence of higher values. The range of subjects combined with the author’s own faith, undogmatic and free of creed, makes it a philosophical education in itself. It was one of the toughest book I had to deal with at that time (1965). Try reading it and you will find it illuminating.

    As Secretary of the Bank, I used to be in the lift (private lift that went straight to the 14th Floor to his Office) to receive him every time. One day, maybe he got on the wrong side of the bed, I greeted him as usual with “Good Morning, Sir”. I was stunned when he replied, “Din, what so good about this morning”. He can be rough and kill you with his monosyllables. I know he was particularly tough on his elder son, Iskandar. But he was bullied by Iskandar’s kids. –Din Merican

  9. There were days of long gone where corporal punishment was exhibited at school assembly. At most, students might release air from teachers’ car tires. Perhaps about 10-15 years back, a group of students set fire to their HM room. Seemed that was SMK Taman Sea if not mistaken? Today?

  10. Since it is story time I must relate a few:

    1. Once while chairing a meeting of officers in my office this Malay officer put up his hand in the middle of the meeting and said: Tuan I want to throw water. “throw water” I was lost till my deputy sitting next to me said, he wants to go to the toilet.Throw water was a direct translation of “buang air”. I nearly fell of my chair but I restrained myself.Thanks to the guy who dropped English language in schools.

    2. Two weeks ago my son was admitted to a private hospital for a minor nose surgery after injuring himself while playing futsal.An Indian nurse appeared after the surgery as his nose was bandaged and asked: “Tambi
    inah shandea ah”(Bro got into a fight) My son told her if that was so he will be in perhaps Klang hospital not in a private hospital.A few hours later a Malay nurse appeared and asked him”adik jatuh motor ke?”
    See what’s in the Malaysian mind: To an Indian having a broken nose means having been wacked up in a fight and to a malay mind it means falling of a motor bike mat remit style!
    See how intelligent our Malaysians have become!

  11. Way back in the mid 1970’s I worked as a temporary teacher in a premier secondary school. naturally as i am a temp i was assigned for poorer classes (above E classes in the alphabetic class nomenclature) of lower secondary (Form 1 and 2).

    I was shocked to discover that students then were unable to read or form proper sentences in English. That is almost 35 years ago. Some could not add proper.

    This was a school in a major town.

    I also think that the rot eroded when we abolished the compulsory passing of LCE / SRP to gain entry into Form 4.

  12. Here is some or alot of help to our EDUCATION minister and all students

    http://www.pearsonhighered.com/educator/product/Asking-the-Right-Questions-A-Guide-to-Critical-Thinking-10E/9780205111169.page

    Pearson Education Inc

    DESCRIPTION

    Used in a variety of courses in various disciplines, Asking the Right Questions helps students bridge the gap between simply memorizing or blindly accepting information, and the greater challenge of critical analysis and synthesis.

    Specifically, this concise text teaches students to think critically by exploring the components of arguments–issues, conclusions, reasons, evidence, assumptions, language–and on how to spot fallacies and manipulations and obstacles to critical thinking in both written and visual communication. It teaches them to respond to alternative points of view and develop a solid foundation for making personal choices about what to accept and what to reject.

  13. NUS, ranked 24 and top of Asia uni, UiTM, ranked >700….? Why ? Too much of BTN stuff and too many Professor Chiplak.., kaki bodek who only know how to kelentong in Bernama TV’s Helo Malaysia show…..

  14. I made this comment when I was in service and I would like to make it again. If we are not that proud at least we should follow Brunei. First six years make National Language the medium of instruction with English as a compulsory subject followed by English as the medium of instruction in secondary and tertiary education with National Language a compulsory subject. The reaction to this comment when I made it was that if I were an absolute Ruler then it could be done.
    And who says that you cannot have your cake and eat it.

  15. Datuk

    Is it by coincidence that this topic surfaces at the same time as the results of ranking of universities in the world are published? What a shame to see how far our universities have fallen down the ladder when 50 -60 years ago UM was at par with University of Singapore and Penang Free School was the premier school not only in Malaysia but also SEA. Today if you visit PFS it is just like another Malay School with nothing to be proud of.
    Don’t expect the education system will improve with the new Education Blueprint. I don’t think it will ever happen.
    The eldest son of the late Tun Ismail Ali, Iskandar was my colleague in Azman Wong Salleh & Co in the early 70s. He was in my audit team and we shared some good stories of his life then.
    ____________
    Hilmi, it is sad. As Old Frees, we lament at what has become of our alma mater, The Penang Free School. Today, our school has been renamed Sekolah Menegah Kebangsaan Penang Free (?). We chose mediocrity in stead of excellence and meritocracy, and we pay a a heavy price for that choice. Cheers, Din

  16. Education in Malaysia has been politicized. The Ministry of Education has long been the training ground for future Prime Ministers. Politicians built the education system but then sent their offsprings overseas for education. It goes to show their own lack of confidence in the system they feel we should support. Today Malaysian grads cannot string a sentence without making some sort of error – spelling and grammatical. What a shame!

  17. http://hbr.org/product/teaching-smart-people-how-to-learn/an/91301-PDF-ENG

    HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW ARTICLE

    Teaching Smart People How to Learn by Chris Argyris

    Source: Harvard Business Review
    14 pages. Publication Date: May 01, 1991. Prod. #: 91301-PDF-ENG

    Competitive success depends on learning, but most people, including professionals in leadership positions, are not very good at it.

    Learning is a function of how people reason about their own behavior. Yet most people engage in defensive reasoning when confronted with problems. They blame others and avoid examining critically the way they have contributed to problems.

    Companies need to make managers’ and employees’ reasoning patterns a focus of continuous improvement efforts

  18. PFS, ASI, UM,Rm,Stocks,Uni ranking etc etc all DOWN.Petrol, food prices,crime,various ops,property,etc etc all UP.Endless Possibilities in a country run by morons!!

  19. we are always lamenting about our education system – how can you expect anything of quality from a bunch of unqualified politicians and civil servants making decisions, the few bright spots among them can’t bring any positive change.

    its time someone sets up a commission to look into their real academic qualifications and how much they paid for these certificates, which is surely from the taxpayers.

  20. I remembered when we were in Form 3 in the 60s during our science class, a girl classmate by the name of Anne if not mistaken suddenly posed a question to the science teacher about how it felt when the thrust of the pen*s when it entered a woman vag***. However the science teacher answered willingly though his face turned red. She is now a doctor in a private hospital.

  21. Malaysia’s National Education Blueprint 2013-2015 stresses to substantially increase the teaching hours of Bahasa Malaysia (Malay) in vernacular schools (Chinese and Indian), and sets extra hours for English in all schools can make Malaysia World-class students?

  22. Rightways, do you think that the Malaysian Chinese can be persuaded to give up their Chinese schools and opt for English-medium schools? These shools will have compulsory mother-tongue languages too but with a proviso that one must pass Malay to obtain a Form V cert?

    I ask because I truly believe that until all Malaysian children go to the same schools now, then there is no hope for their own children because by then, racial polarisation will have turned into racial riots.

    Forget how good the Chinese schools are. We have to start to re-build the Penang Free Schools of this world and make these national schools as good as they were again.

    If the Chinese can be made to sacrifice something as precious as their mother-tongue schools, perhaps the Malays too, can be persuaded to accept that English-medium schools is the most sensible way forward, not just for unity, but for Malaysia in the 21st Century.

  23. Here’s a remedy:

    http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-09-13/wharton-puts-first-year-mba-courses-online-for-free#r=most popular

    The Business Week Magazine
    Wharton Puts First-Year MBA Courses
    Online for Free: By Louis Lavelle September 13, 2013

    Getting a Wharton MBA involves taking off from work for two years, moving to Philadelphia, and spending about $200,000 on tuition and expenses. Now, with the addition of three new courses on the online learning platform Coursera, you can get much of the course content for free. http://blog.coursera.org/post/60889088289/the-wharton-mba-foundation-series

    While you won’t get the full Wharton on-campus experience—or an internship, career services, or alumni network, for that matter—the new courses in financial accounting, marketing, and corporate finance duplicate much of what you would learn during your first year at the elite business school, says Don Huesman, managing director of the innovation group at Wharton.

    A fourth course in operations management that’s been offered since September rounds out the “foundation series.” Along with five existing electives, which include courses on sports business and health care, the new offerings make it possible to learn much of what students in Wharton’s full-time MBA program learn, and from the same professors. All nine courses are massive open online courses, or MOOCs, expected to attract students from around the world.

    “This is the first time that a business school has bundled a collection of MOOCs together in this fashion,” Huesman says of the foundation series. “We’re taking our core required classes in the MBA program, with the same instructors, to provide those same core concepts.”

    All four courses in the foundation series are 6 to 10 weeks long, with the first, financial accounting, starting on Sept. 16. Each consists of a combination of prerecorded lectures and interactive features, such as discussion boards that allow students to ask questions and get answers from the professor or an assistant.

    Huesman says the MOOCs are not watered-down versions of Wharton’s on-campus classes. In fact, some professors at the school are using the MOOC content in their own classes, asking students to watch the lessons beforehand so that class time can be used for discussion—a practice known as “flipping” a class.

    Students in all four courses are eligible, for a $49 fee, to receive a verified electronic certificate indicating that they’ve completed the course requirements.

    Huesman says Wharton has no plans to accept the certificates for course credit should students subsequently enroll at Wharton, adding that “there’s a very different experience that happens in a two-year immersion in a community of scholars that culminates in a degree.” But he says what students learn in the online classes can be used to “test out” of required courses just as those with knowledge of the subject matter can do now.

    About 700,000 students in 173 countries have already enrolled in Wharton MOOCs, more than the combined enrollment in Wharton’s traditional MBA and undergraduate programs since the school’s founding in 1881, according to Huesman. Additional courses are in the pipeline, he says.

  24. Pingback: Kurikulum Pembelajaran Anak ABK Mengacu Pada Badan Standart Nasional Pendidikan (BSNP) | Anak ABK

  25. Pingback: Metode Pembelajaran | Anak ABK

  26. Ai Tze , don’t think English can make Malaysia world-class in future.

    The world is changing fast, we need our citizens to know other important languages too, not just English and Malay and blame Chinese!!

  27. Pingback: Penyusunan Rancangan Program Homeschooling Privat Terapi ke Rumah Anak ABK | Anak ABK

  28. Let’s take a break away from all th cries of deteriorating educational system in our country and trace the excellance that prevailed in the 50’s, 60’s and the 70’s. Going to school was such fun and passing in exams are a normal part of life at that time. However the education system, the dedicated teachers and the social integration of the students in the schools are far more advanced than present. We studied with our hearts and understood what education is all about. Teachers are more than dedicated in moulding a student not forgetting their sacrifices towards forming more disciplined society. After the 80’s what we saw was the meddling of the education system by unwarranted hands. Changing the education system many times to suit the current political and social scenario. Even the teachers couldn’t get accustomed to the present system. There are times teaching of Maths And Science in English was twice reverted. Teaching was focussed more on exam orientation rather than anlysing, assessing and understanding. The social behaviorial aspects between students have also been eroded. Thinking about walking along memory lane gives a bitter experience. We hope our generations to come will inherit some old golden experiences of the 50’s , 60’s and the 70’s.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.