US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton breaks new ground in Myanmar


December 1, 2011

http://www.washingtonpost.com

US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton breaks new ground in Myanmar

by William Wan

The highest-ranking U.S. official to set foot in Myanmar( Burma)’s Presidential Palace, Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton on Thursday brought a message of praise to Burma’s President for his nascent gestures of reform even as she warned him that significantly more progress was needed for change to take root.

The table may be set for “a new chapter in our shared history,” Clinton said at a news conference shortly after the meeting, adding that “while the measures already taken may be unprecedented and welcomed, they are just a beginning.”

For weeks leading up to Clinton’s visit, the Obama administration had emphasized cautious optimism in dealing with authoritarian and reclusive leaders of Myanmar(Burma) — a country with a long history of repression and strife that has seen promises of progress dissipate before, and in some case, devolve into brutal and lethal crackdowns.

Seeking to allay such doubts, Myanmar (Burma)’s President Thein Sein spent much of their meeting giving a detailed 45-minute presentation to Clinton about further change, according to U.S. officials. His plan for reforming areas of his government long criticized by the U.S. and others included: the gradual release of political prisoners, a cease-fire in the war between Burma’s military and ethnic minorities, political reform, media freedom and adopting international agreements on nuclear programs to allay suspicions about Burma-North Korea weapons trades.

Clinton said she responded by telling him that the United States will ”match action with action” — greater aid, economic rewards and diplomatic prestige in return for bolder reforms.

Thein Sein and others in his government have pushed repeatedly for Washington to lift economic sanctions against Burma — viewed as the ultimate prize for their overtures to the West.

In their meeting Thursday, Clinton offered the Myanmese (Burmese) significantly smaller incentives in hopes of nudging them forward without giving up too much too fast. She discussed U.S. support for loosening restrictions on health and microfinancing programs by the United Nations and offered U.S. support for exploring other international aid.

The most direct result of the meeting, however, could be a restoration of U.S. diplomatic relations and an upgrade of Burma’s mission into a full embassy with a U.S. ambassador — something Clinton said she discussed with the Burmese officials.

The historic exchanges on Thursday suggest Burma, also known as Myanmar, could become the long desired example of success for the Obama administration’s approach to oppressive regimes. His early pledge — to reach out to those despotic governments who “unclench their first” — has largely gone unanswered for two years.

Iran has become increasingly isolated with Western powers now pulling out diplomats fearing for their safety. North Korea has remained as defiant as ever — launching provocative attacks last year on South Korea, perhaps the closest U.S. ally in Asia. And Syria remains embroiled in its brutal repression of a revolution.

From that bleak global picture, Burma’s political and economic reform emerged suddenly and unexpectedly, U.S. officials said.

“It was good policy by the Obama administration, but they also, to a degree, got lucky,” said Ernie Bower, a Southeast Asia expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

While much has been made of Burma’s recent overtures to the West as an attempt to guard itself from an increasingly powerful and assertive China, the change is also believed to be result of internal politics among its secretive leaders — power dynamics U.S. officials readily admit they still do not understand — and fear that the country is falling far behind its neighbors because of its isolation and international sanctions.

12 thoughts on “US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton breaks new ground in Myanmar

  1. Hillary Clinton handled Myanmar with respect and made a good first impression. Let us hope the military junta will pursue the path of democratic reforms, and benefit from better relations with the US. It will also be good for ASEAN.

  2. A good first visit… to hosts who were gracious… but time will tell.

    Thankfully there were no lectures on democracy and human rights.

  3. I betcha when Hillary was strolling among the stupas in Shwedagon this evening, she heard her friend’s voice:

    What a voice!

  4. US politicians behaved like God going around preaching/lecturing you and everybody to reform, do this, do that in American ways, but they themselves need more reforms like American own structural problems, jobless youths, high unemployment, economic woes, heavy debts, foreclosures of properties, banks failed, rating cuts …….

    The truths are USA needs your supports, buy more American military equipment, establish allies ….

  5. Look, US’s lectures on democracy and human rights again, with American aid too!

    Clinton challenges Burma to expand reforms
    December 1, 2011 – 10:54PM:

    AFP

    US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton has challenged the leaders of Burma to continue and expand recent reforms.

    She is calling for the release of all political prisoners, an end to violent campaigns against ethnic minorities and a breaking of military ties with North Korea.

    “We believe that any political prisoner anywhere should be released,” Clinton told reporters during the first visit to this long-isolated nation by the top US diplomat in more than 50 years.

    “One political prisoner is one too many in our view.”

    Clinton made her comments ahead of a meeting with the most famous political prisoner of all, opposition leader and Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi, who was released last year after two decades of on-and-off imprisonment and has said she will run in upcoming elections.

    Meeting earlier with President Thein Sein and other senior government officials in the capital of Naypyidaw, Clinton offered a small package of rewards for steps it had already taken but made clear that more must be done.

    “I came to assess whether the time is right for a new chapter in our shared history,” she said, adding that the US was ready to further improve relations with the civilian government in the South-East Asian nation but only if it stays on the path of democratisation.

    In a series of modest first steps, she announced that Washington would allow Burma’s participation in a US-backed grouping of Mekong River countries; no longer block enhanced cooperation between the country and the International Monetary Fund; and support intensified UN health, microfinance and counternarcotics programs.

    A senior US official said Thein Sein had outlined his government’s plans for reform in a 45-minute presentation in which he acknowledged that Burma lacked a recent tradition of democracy and openness.

    He asked for US help in making the transition from military to full civilian rule, according to the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity to describe the private diplomatic exchange.

    Clinton replied that she was visiting because the US was “encouraged by the steps that you and your government have taken to provide for your people”.

    Yet, she also made clear that those steps must be consolidated and enlarged if the US is to consider easing near-blanket economic sanctions that block almost all American commercial transactions with Burma.

    “While measures already taken may be unprecedented and certainly welcome, they are just a beginning,” she told reporters.

    “We’re not at the point yet where we can consider lifting sanctions that we have in place because of our ongoing concerns about policies that have to be reversed,” Clinton said.

    “But any steps that the government takes will be carefully considered and will be matched.”

    She called for the release of political prisoners and an end to brutal ethnic violence that has ravaged the nation for decades.

    She also warned the country’s leadership to break suspected illicit military, nuclear and ballistic missile co-operation with North Korea that may violate UN sanctions.

    “Better relations with the United States will only be possible if the entire government respects the international consensus against the spread of nuclear weapons … and we support the government’s stated intention to sever military ties with North Korea,” she said.

    © 2011 AFP

  6. Well, the Burmese can take it or leave it, righto..
    But my suspicion is that the Burmese will do a ‘Vietnam-like’ transformation, if their Paramount leader (Than Shwee) allows – but at an accelerated pace – ‘cuz they have much more natural resources (that the PRC covets). They may yet come in from the Cold as defined by what the West and their Asian allies deem as Right.

    Now this Right may be your Wrong, but learn to live with it! No use being the mouthpiece of your PRC masters. In many ways, no one can control the outcome. Burma has to accept lasting peace with their ethnic minorities and compromise with the ‘weak’ NLD+allies, if they don’t want to end up like PRC’s other perpetual-proxy-pariah, N.Korea.

    You see, Chinese Grandees always lecture from a perspective of ‘strength’ and power. The West often lectures on the need for the weak and poor to be heard. Why? It’s like gravity – the weakest of the 4 fundamental forces of physics. But when you fall – it hurts.

    It is also said: “The Weak shall inherit the Earth.” Thus, the Weak loving Gwai-Lo Retards somehow managed to build the mightiest war-machine the world has ever seen. They’ve adopted the yin-yang dichotomy even though it was supposed to be a very ancient Chinese discovery. Why?

    But I doubt you understand. After all money can only go so far. For instance, building Naypyidaw in an isolated place so that the US marines, like Semper Fi can’t breach.. Paranoia.

    BTW, how’s PRC’s Space-Station coming along? Could you please tell them to stop painting those huge geometric designs in the Gobi Desert as grid references to calibrate their spy satellites? Bad for the environment.

  7. The US move is pragmatic and builds on ASEAN’s decision to allow Myanmar to take the ASEAN Chairmanship in 2014. It is important for ASEAN and its partners to enmesh Myanmar through various levels of engagement be it in economic, social or other areas to reduce the likelihood of Myanmar regressing to its isolationist ways.

    At the end of the day the question that ought to be asked is whether Myanmar can afford the Chairmanship. Under normal circumstances the ASEAN Chair would benefit from the vast sums of money that would be spent by the other delegations when they attend meetings. But that argument only holds true if the host country has the requisite hard and soft infrastructures to capture this money.

    Therefore ASEAN has more than one reason to take the lead in encouraging Myanmar to introduce economic reforms to modernize its regulatory framework and bring its tax and investment codes up to date. Better business environment will help the country improve its economic and physical infrastructure which in turn would allow the country to reap the benefits of the ASEAN Chairmanship.

    ASEAN and its partners should also encourage Myanmar to spread the ASEAN meetings in other cities besides Yangon so that the benefit of Chairmanship can be enjoyed by a broader section of the population.
    ____________
    Observer,

    2014 is 3 years from now. This means that Myanmar must hasten the pace of its economic, social and political reforms (more openness, democracy and economic liberalisation). Getting its politics right (as in the case of Cambodia which emerged from its dark days since 1991 after the Paris Peace Accord and UNTAC) is, therefore, essential.

    Yes ASEAN can help, but ASEAN must get its own act together, be more action driven and results oriented and less of a talk shop with meetings galore. I think, the Americans are beginning to see the strategic importance of Myanmar, which could be a base for China’s expanding blue water navy in the Indian Ocean. At the end of the day, the US, India and China will,in my view, be the key players in the winning the hearts and minds of the military junta in Naypyidaw.

    The incentive based approach might work to bring about democratic change. ASEAN’s constructive engagement with Myanmar failed because the regional organization does not have money to back its engagement process.–Din Merican

  8. By all means enmesh Myanmar into everything that is going on in the region…. such engagement is THE best way forward. But ASEAN (and ASIA as a whole) must keep the US at arm’s length… otherwise all we shall have to show for it in the long term are bases, weapons and soldiers.Study the recent past and see what I mean

    So while the recent US “visit” was cordial, let us leave it at that and no more.

    ASIA has vast problems ahead for sure but we are a relatively peaceful region and, most importantly, nobody is threathening anybody.If and when a threat does arise Asians will solve it better alone.

    LET ASIANS RUN ASIA…

  9. Good views, ocho onda

    Right, LET ASIANS RUN ASIA…Isa Manteqi

    Asians are among friends, unlike outside forces from the Western powers and USA who have always sanctioned and conquered everywhere in the world. Burma was colonized by the British, economic sanctioned by US who should now remove it for win-win deals.

  10. “Asians are among friends” righto

    Huh?!
    Don’t you know there’s a “War of Mung Beans” going on right now? PRC traders have cornered the market, and the ASEAN importers in this precious commodity are crying foul! I’ll have you know that the gross Chinapek refuse to share the Mung beans they have purchased on ‘futures’ in Burma and India.
    How to be friends, when they refuse to share the precursor to Taugeh, glass noodles and kacang putih? Maybe that’s why you guys are constipated.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.