Malay uber alles, above everybody else

December 27, 2019

Malay uber alles, above everybody else

by  S. Thayaparan


COMMENT | After Harapan won the last election, I assumed we had some breathing space.

“So I urge young Malays to plan their lives properly. Don’t make the same mistake I did. Malaysia is a sick Muslim country that teaches you the wrong things.”

– Zaid Ibrahim

The recent comments by BN secretary-general Nazri Abdul Aziz on the Semenyih campaign trail about the racist inclination of the UMNO grassroots on their fear of non-Malays leading certain ministerial portfolios is neither shocking nor unexpected.

All this is part of the Malay über alles strategy of the far right and the foundation of mainstream Malay politics. Non-Malay political operatives in Pakatan Harapan, now that the coalition has achieved federal power, have to be careful about how they define their power because everyone has been told not to spook the Malays.

Furthermore, because Bersatu was not the powerhouse Malay bloc that Harapan had hoped for, the old maverick has had to resort to all sorts of stratagems to entice UMNOmno political operatives to step into his tent.

All this, of course, plays into the hands of UMNO and PAS who can now freely explore their racial and supremacist ideologies without fear of losing their non-Malay base because the MCA and MIC are out of play.

Two years ago, former minister Zaid Ibrahim, encouraged young Malays to leave this country because of the policies of BN. This, of course, caused a stir. As always, whenever Zaid says something, he does so without political consideration. He spits it out because he knows that outlier Malay voices think this way.

There were the usual calls to stay and fight by those in the intelligentsia who supported the then opposition Harapan. I was sceptical. In a piece exploring what Zaid actually said – there is always confusion because some pundits do not bother to refer to what he said, instead relying on what others claim he said – I wrote:

“If you want people to stay and fight for their rights, you must be able to demonstrate that staying and fighting is something that is worthwhile. We are not yet at the stage where you can point to incremental changes (elsewhere) and say that this is progress. We are a developed country with narratives that are evidence that religious and racial plurality is something we had, but lost like many Islamic state narratives in countries all over the Middle East.”

After Harapan won the last election, I assumed we had some breathing space. To my thinking and I suppose some people who voted for Harapan, we believed that if we begin the process – however incrementally – of dismantling the Malay uber alles ideology, we could at least set the foundation for a brighter tomorrow for future generations. This kind of thinking is not based on any idealist impulses. This is pure self-preservation. People sometimes confuse capitulation with pragmatism.

But as the days drag on, I see very little hope or evidence that things are going to change. While I received the usual hate mail for my last piece from the usual suspects, I received many emails from Malays overseas, who claimed that what Zaid two years ago was the right thing to do.

Many young Malays ask me how they can overcome a system which is against them, but which people think provides privileges for them? Zaid said it best: “They will continue to make you intellectually poor by stifling you, giving you no freedom to grow and develop your minds.”

As one young Malay activist told me, there is this bubble we exist in. There is some freedom in the political/activist circles, but it slowly evaporates depending on where you go. Non-Malays, although they face discrimination, do not have to look over their shoulder all the time in case they are targeted by the religious bureaucracy or they are sanctioned for making racially provocative statements which are in reality egalitarian statements.


Umno political operatives make an argument about how “immigrants” assimilate in the West “Western” culture and norms, so why can’t the non-Malays do it here too? This is a silly argument because assimilation of Western culture generally means assimilating democratic and egalitarian norms and not sublimating culture to Islam and racial hegemony which is what is expected of the non-Malays here.

Please note, I am not saying that the “West” is perfect, only that assimilation in the West means submitting to a whole different set of values which are more aligned to democratic first principles, rather than being pak turuts (yes-men) which is how someone like PAS leader Abdul Hadi Awang and the rest of the Malay political elite sees the non-Malays. Are there extremists in the West pushing a right-wing Judeo/Christian agenda? Yes, but we should note the blow-back this agenda receives.

Say what you like about Nazri, but he is saying exactly what the Malay grassroots believe, and keep in mind this is the base that Bersatu and other Malay power structures in Harapan want.

How can you change this sort of thinking? How long will it take? A generation? Two generations? The non-Malays are losing the numbers game and in a couple of decades, will there be any young Malays who would even think of migrating because of a totalitarian government?

People often ask what can they do. I have no idea. I cannot point to alternatives in mainstream political parties. Young people who have left the country and who correspond with me, tell me the same thing. There are no mainstream alternatives in the Malaysian political landscape. One Malay power structure is the same as the next.

Lawyer Latheefa Koya correctly points out that Nazri’s comments are an insult to Malays, but so is claiming Malays need a party to defend them, that Islam needs to be protected, the Malays are under siege and the DAP is working to destroy Malay rule in Malaysia.

If Nazri is being investigated for sedition, then perhaps, the mainstream political system in Malaysia is seditious.

S THAYAPARAN is Commander (Rtd) of the Royal Malaysian Navy. A retired barrister-at-law, he is one of the founding members of the National Patriots Association.

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.

7 thoughts on “Malay uber alles, above everybody else

  1. There shall be no change for a better and brighter future , if the people regardless, should ask themselves and decide to take actions whether :

    They want to accept the post Tunku era of Umnob -Mahathir’s “my way “or no other ways of governance-Where slogans and rethorics speaks louder than actions, for one main reason in sustaining power for self-serving interest and “stealing ” country’s huge wealth in cohort with the cronies, leaving little benefit to the people——-all in the name of Islam or the unlimited rights of Malay race, through media hypocrisy and fake news/ policies, abuse of power and corruptios ,rather than helping the poor honestly and diligently.


    Malaysians regardless , have to make up the mind and decide for themselves, to show their displeasure, beginning with Semenyih state by-election.

    Migration is not the solution.
    This country NEEDS to Start on a. Clean Slate!

    We, the people, are the solutions.
    Trust our Wisdom and Unwavering Loyalty to the Malaysia we and our forefathers had founded and fought for.

  2. What Nazri says does not scare me. What really scares me is UKM students not telling Najib off in public but even actually welcoming and listening to his crap. Dissatisfaction with PH is not an excuse to not reject the absolute wrong. Its weak and a social problem..

    Malay uber alles? They are jumping into self-destruction all on their own..

  3. This article points to the REAL MALAY DILEMMAS created by Mahathirism and parochialism that will stifle MALAYS developments for generations to come, if AWAKENING from this stifling by the PARTY STATE and RELIGIOUS shackles is not removed.

    Without the removals, these shackles will impede their maturing of minds towards independence and will constantly be under the stifling controls of DICTATOR like Mahathir now or someone similar.

    Why ketuanan Melayu will not be relevant? Because in the next few decades, Malaysia’s demographics will be closer to 70% Malays and politically non- Malays is politically non issue.

    Please remember the HILTER’s Supremacy Syndrome that fell on its own sword eventually.

    Mahathir is no difference to Hilter except that Hilter is not greedy, thats mean something.

  4. I lamented to disagreed on one point .

    There was BERSIH , the CLEAN and, POWERFUL “mainstream alternative” that cuts across all racial and religiou, cultural ,ethnic and institutional lines.

    But its platform was HIJACKED by Mahathir and now almost destroyed .

    Bersih or its equivalent could be revived and reinvented !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.