Fake degrees and fake reforms

February 9,2019

Fake degrees and fake reforms

Opinion  |  S. Thayaparan

Ong said given the more serious nature of the revelation, Najib must ask the two ministers to quit to reflect his seriousness in upholding accountability.”

Malay Mail, June 26, 2013

DAP’s Dr. ONG  Kian Ming

A politician lies or spins, works the party system, makes alliances and enemies and generally does despicable deeds to court votes, and you do not need a professional qualification to do this.–S. Thayaparan

 Note. Dr. Ong Kian Ming (Chinese: 王建民; pinyin: Wángjiànmín; born 12 September 1975), is a Malaysian politician from the Democratic Action Party (DAP), a component of Pakatan Harapan (PH) coalition. He is the incumbent Member of Parliament for Bangi since 2018 and also when the constituency was still named as Serdang earlier since 2013. Ong was picked as the Deputy Minister of International Trade and Industry by the new PH government in 2018.[1]

Ong was formerly an academic and a prominent political analyst in the Malaysian political scene before he turned Election Strategist for the DAP.[2][3][4] His articles were widely published in popular news portals such as Malaysiakini, Malaysian Insider and The Edge.[5] Prior to that he was a lecturer in Faculty of Economics and Policy Science, UCSI University, also a regional consultant for the Blue Ocean Strategy regional center. His experience includes being a policy analyst for Socio- Economics Development and Research Institute (SEDAR) and Institute of Strategic Analysis and Policy Research (INSAP). In addition, he was also associate consultant for the Boston Consulting Group Kuala Lumpur.

COMMENT | I really did not want to get into this whole “fake degree” fiasco but then I read Deputy International Trade and Industry Minister Ong Kian Ming’s piece about not needing a degree to be an effective politician and realised how much trouble we are in. Ong couldn’t even bring himself to name the minister in question, and chose instead to backtrack on earlier positions he held while maintaining he has been consistent.

Ong’s piece is politics at its most craven. Ong is half-right. You do not need professional qualifications to be an effective politician. However, professional qualifications most times add a veneer of legitimacy to mendacious politics because people are conditioned to think that professional degrees add an element of credibility to political rhetoric.

But it adds very little to actual governing and policy-making which entails a different set of skill sets, most importantly political will.

Ong says that a professional qualification is not needed to be an effective politician. This is true. A politician lies or spins, works the party system, makes alliances and enemies and generally does despicable deeds to court votes, and you do not need a professional qualification to do this.

Do all politicians do this? Maybe not, but mainstream political parties are filled with elected politicians who do this.

Furthermore, Ong now claims that when being part of the government or a ministry, “it is more important for you to know your scope of work and your policy responsibilities. Having done a degree may be helpful in training you to think more broadly and critically and hence, better equip you to govern. But it is not guaranteed.”

With regards to “degree mills”, Ong said: “My stand on this issue is clear and has not changed. It is not acceptable for politicians to buy degrees from degree mills and then try to pass these off as being genuine academic degrees.”

On this issue, Ong’s stand is not clear. I would argue his stand on this issue was clear but since coming to federal power his stand has been reversed. What Ong says now is radically different from what he said back in the day. The justification he is making now is a mockery of what this Pakatan Harapan reform government is supposed to be about. It does, however, demonstrate that Harapan operatives are excelling in back-pedalling.

In 2013, Ong had asked then Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak to sack two ministers who Ong claimed had fake degrees. If anything, his stand then was clear.

Two points need to be understood when considering Ong’s change of position. And this is so funny because the headline for the report blares out “Sack ministers with dubious degrees, DAP MP tells PM”.

The first, Ong has a clear position on this issue and demanded the resignation of ministers with fake degrees.

“It is truly disappointing that on the first day for ministerial replies in the first parliamentary sitting since the 13th general election, Malaysians have to accept the reality that Prime Minister Najib Razak has appointed two ministers with two dodgy degrees each from institutions which are degree mills.”

The second, Ong shifts the goal posts. In his piece yesterday, he claimed that not having a degree does not necessarily impede a politician’s ability to carry out his policy responsibilities but the question here is, does having a fake degree impede the minster’s ability to carry out his responsibility? We should refer to what Ong said before Harapan came into federal power:

“Therefore, to entrust two ministers with fake degrees with the serious responsibilities of human capital development and the management of certifications and standards is not only a gross embarrassment but also most ironic for a prime minister who has made transformation his clarion call.”

Bending over backwards

Should the police investigate someone for having a degree from a degree mill or a fake degree? Probably not. But if having a fake degree is part of the systemic corruption that someone like Ong used to rail against, then why is Ong now making all these justifications for a member of his coalition?

Ong asked then Prime Minister Najib for the resignation of the two ministers in 2013 and asked for the ministers to resign to prove their commitment to reform. Why is Ong not asking the current Prime Mminister Dr Mahathir Mohamad for the resignation of Deputy Foreign Minister Marzuki Yahya (photo)? Why is he not asking Marzuki to resign? Why is he not asking for the Harapan political elite to demonstrate they are committed to reforms?

In 2013, Ong made the case that fake degrees hamper the ability of ministers to effectively carry out their policy responsibilities. He called it an embarrassment for the reform agenda of the Najib regime. Now when a deputy minister who has to be a credible spokesperson for Malaysia has been caught with a fake degree, why isn’t Ong applying the same standards?

Does Ong really believe that his position has not changed? Does Ong really believe that his muted goal posts-shifting piece about fake degrees is really the way how to reform the system? I mean, does anyone else realise how funny this is?

Bersatu Deputy President Mukhriz Mahathir said that Marzuki was not appointed for his academic credentials and here we have Ong telling people that academic qualifications do not necessarily mean a minister would be good at his job, which directly contradicts what he said back in the day when he was going after the UMNO regime. Is there some sort of collaboration when it comes to shovelling the horse manure or do Harapan political operatives all think the same way?

Now people may say this is not a big issue. Truth be told, I am not really bothered by politicians who go around carrying fake degrees. As far as I am concerned, all the ministerial appointments have been a dodgy affair and it would not matter if the appointees had sterling academic qualifications. The reality is that most of them are not really interested in reform or do not have any ideas for reforming the system.

What is alarming is the way how politicians who used to claim to want to reform the system and hold the government accountable are now bending over backwards to defend issues which before they came into power they claimed were indefensible.

The question is not how Marzuki can be a credible Deputy Minister but how those who backtrack on their positions just to defend Marzuki be credible reformers?

S THAYAPARAN is Commander (Rtd) of the Royal Malaysian Navy. A retired barrister-at-law, he is one of the founding members of Persatuan Patriot Kebangsaan.

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.



8 thoughts on “Fake degrees and fake reforms

  1. The reason why Ong does not ask him to resign is simple. He does not want to kick a own goal. I believe that he has left it to Marzuki to make the right decision and resign on his own. Or to PM Mahathir to take action. As it is, there is simply too many people in government and opposition making too many observations and distracting the government from doing why they ought to be doing – governing.
    Besides does a fake university degree really mean anything especially since he did not use that qualification to get his job.I have met and worked with government officers with not just degrees and MBAs from recognised universities from local and foreign universities and simply did not measure up. Surely that is now common public.

  2. The Commander is just choosing to pick PH failures because he does not see how else he can comment to make a real difference. It may be honest desire and intention but its not intellectual honesty.

    Its simple to understand why OKM has slipped to defend his fellow ministerial colleague. Towering pinciple and ideas does not amount to a hill of bean when you are strained and pressured by realities of severe failures. It’s horrible feeling when those we trust and rely on fails us.

    Faced with realities, we can choose to only criticise when it moves us or we can choose to think, learn more to grapple the problem wholly.

    Fact is the problem is human failing of severe consequences that can ruin a good a necessary thing. What to do with such a conundrum? It’s not so simple and OKM rush to fix it with his mistake screams things are very bad. The fake degree nor OKM misspeaking is the issue. The issue is PH has severe problems with poor, little or maybe no option.

  3. “Ong’s piece is politics at its most craven.”

    Absolutely, Cdr.
    Like many of his hypocritical self-interest colleagues from the rabid Red Bean Otak party.

    Remember the vulgar, foul mouthed Superman Hew Flur? Now, the ‘CEO’ of the Malaysian-China Business Council? Flur garnered a PhD in ‘DAP politics’ from the Chinese University of HK. Of what utility has this so called diploma for advancement of human knowledge – is way beyond my ken. Probably just much as from UMNOb’s frozen Prez, Zahoot with his PhD dissertation on UMNOb ‘Poolitics’ from our most vaunted Defense Varsity.

    Then we have the super-duper Ms Yeo Bee Yin of OKM’s party who seems to be eminently academically qualified to be an efficacious Min of MOSTI – but is probably more interested in Marrying herself off to a scion of one of Malaysia’s tycoon family. Whacks up LYNAS without realizing the consequences of her actions on our FDIs. Meanwhile allows just as polluting Glass manufacturing and Plastic recycling factories to sprout willy nilly.

    As for Mdm Teresa Kok, nothing needs to be said as her ability is about as confrontational as can be – especially when our commodity prices are at it’s lowest ebb. Why whack WHO for an anti-Palm Oil report when she should have defended by publishing a counter is way beyond fighter-cock sensibilities.

    Et cetera, for almost all Ministries as Malaysia marches on the spot and starts sliding towards the Abyss – not only created by UMNOb/Kleptos – but by the present Kakistocrats.

    So yes, Mr Ong, you are a Joke and an irrelevant one eye wonder.

    After all, Octo is satisfied with the performance of these ‘satisfactory’ ministers. What does it take to satisfy a 93 year old self proclaimed genius?

  4. Now Marzuki says he’s not guilty. Guilty of what? Nobody is accusing him of a crime we are just questioning his integrity, dumb idiot of a Dy Foreign Minister.
    Che Det need to just let him go before things get worse.

  5. PH Penipu Haram.

    Inept, totally incompetent.

    Officer having fake qualifications definitely not a prerequisite to hold a political post but definitely necessary if you professed to be qualified.

    Its like getting fake driving or pilot licence to fly a plane.

    Can the public trust such fake officers akin to fake doctor.

    PM7, a real doctor with fake intends for Malaysia’s future, thats the BIGGEST FAKER in the Universe.

  6. Cmdr, time to be kiasu has dawned, since Tun Dr is set to sunset the nation’s future with him. After Tun Dr, there is really none. All should consider the meaning of being kiasu for oneself in this age of Welayu while there is time. Dr Ong has a PhD in political science. His action speaks volume on this state of Welayu. Time to be kiasu! No love needed for the second caste. Love notes to the Melayu, the first, why bother? Time for them to merantau to appreciate what the second caste has experienced. Let the Bersatu best debater in Asia Melayu kid go figure what to do with their own life.. Consider UMNo really has all the wealth, it is really a golden time for all those who has the qualifications to berkatak to UMNo and do some privatisation of interest, and nationalization of risk in UmNo. Dr Ong, there is more money in Barisan, baby. But, oh well, Dr Ong has a PhD from Duke. Dr Ong knows what’s best for himself.

  7. I generally agree with CLF on the qualities of the “red bean party” ministers but can find room to forgive them because of their youth and inexperience (with perhaps the exception of T. Kok). OKM slipped this time, and the only excuse I can find for him is also the most obvious: generally speaking, real degree or false degree, Harapan members tend to try their best to serve the nation and not their wallets. So it’s quite natural for OKM to see something dastardly when some BN ministers tried to palm off a bought degree but less upset when his fellow Harapan member does the same thing. An understandable reaction, though not a sagacious one.

Leave a Reply to bigjoe99 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.