A neo-BN New Year

December 31, 2018 Opinion  |  S Thayaparan

A neo-BN New Year


Opinion  |  S Thayaparan
Published:  |


“For last year’s words belong to last year’s language

And next year’s words await another voice.

And to make an end is to make a beginning.” (Little Gidding)

TS Eliot

COMMENT | Another new year is upon us. I know some people feel as if Pakatan Harapan is the new BN. I have pushed this narrative in nearly all my writings. I desperately sound the alarm bells that Harapan is becoming neo BN – but I do not do this out of spite.

I do this because I come from a generation that saw how BN evolved. A generation that witnessed alliance politics morph into something ugly but more importantly, saw how the public supported a corrupt system out of pragmatism or fear or just plain self-interest.

Image result for lim kit siang

I remember when Lim Kit Siang and the opposition were decimated in one election, and how those of us who were rooting for him were shocked that people did not vote for at least the DAP, which offered something else to the politics that were tearing us apart. However, this is the past. Admittedly, things have changed.

These days I see articulate young leaders toe the party line. I see young leaders more interested in maintaining party discipline, egged on by the base who assume that they speak for all Malaysians.

I see a kind of fascistic patina slowly forming around young leaders more interested in inter-party ascendance than inspiring people – young people especially – that things can change if only you worked hard enough for it. Hate to break it to you but playing the political party game works well on social media but it doesn’t inspire people – especially young people – to vote for the change they want.

It is pointless chronicling the whys and hows of the fall of Najib Abdul Razak. When the old maverick claims that Bersatu was needed in the removal of Najib, I think it is more complicated than that. I think he was needed for the removal of Najib.

Image result for political frogs in malaysia


UMNO Kataks have morphed into  Neo-Bersatus  

Dr. Mahathir Mohamad always knew how to play the political game better than his comrades in UMNO. If Najib had just listened to him, I doubt we would be having this conversation.Image result for Dr.mahathir the maverick


However, the removal of Najib is more than just the legacy of the old maverick. It demonstrated that a ruling coalition could fall. I want young people to take note of this. From what I gather, young people are infatuated with the old maverick and while I understand this, I hope the young people who were standing in the sidelines in the 14th general election now understand the future of this country – and more importantly, the power they could wield in determining this future.

Going through my files, I reread an article in the BBC earlier this year about the power young Malaysians have but do not wield. It is an interesting article, not only because it neatly condensed many of the data points that I have put forward concerning the youth vote in this country but it also reminds us that young people have the power to change things.

“If this is genuine lack of interest, it is reflected in one poll by Merdeka Center, an independent Malaysian polling organisation which last year looked at how young people in West Malaysia felt about politics. Merdeka Center found that as many as 70 percent of them do not believe that their vote will bring about tangible changes in the government and don’t think their elected representatives really care about people like them.”

Young voters are the key, even if they do not care. Look, while I think that DAP, PKR, and Amanah are making an effort, I also think that there are many young people in Bersatu who know that things need to change. I mean, look at someone like Wan Saiful Wan Jan. Smart guy, but he has to conform to the politics of Bersatu, which is an early UMNO pastiche.

Honestly, I tried to give Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman (photo) the benefit of the doubt but if someone like Wan Saiful had brought the kind of American-inspired conservatism to Bersatu, which is what he did when he was in Institute for Democracy and Economic Affairs (Ideas), this would have been a good thing. Bersatu, whether we like it or not, has the best chance to lead the way but if it continues down this path, we are going down the crapper.

Jostling for power, contracts

Change does not take time. Political will stalls for time. We can move forward slowly or you could convince people that you are moving, but walking slowly on the same spot. I keep getting these clips of the old maverick saying that the education policy needs to change. I keep seeing young and old political operatives in Bersatu talking about how the Malays cannot rely on the tongkat and Bersatu needs to lead the way.

I have heard all this before. Maybe you have too. Take education for instance. Firstly, why doesn’t someone give Azly Rahman a job sorting this mess out, but more importantly, if Bersatu and Harapan have the political will to slowly remove the tongkat and change the education system, they would make some good faith gestures.

First, they would recognise the Unified Examination Certificate (UEC). Then they would do away with Malay-only institutions. They would recognise the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (Icerd) for instance, and not in various political ways, propagate the “do not spook the Malays” meme.

What we are hearing from the supposedly closed-door Bersatu AGM is the same game of federal control, of power, through proxies. This is why people are jostling for power, contracts and positions. Decentralise power, which would allow state-level affirmative action programmes for all races. I bet my last ringgit that more Malays would benefit from these programmes than non-Malays, if that is the fear of Malay and non-Malay political operatives.

This way you could name the new agenda the Best Ultra Malay Initiative – BUMI – and nobody would care if everyone was getting the help they need, regardless of race. But everyone knows what separates Bersatu and the far right of Umno and PAS – polemics not policy.

And while I am bitching about policy, this 1am closing time for nightspots in the Federal Territory is the dumbest and I would say a mendacious policy of the Harapan regime. Interfering in business – the price of KFC too high, really? Is it mendacious when you claim we have a trillion ringgit debt?

There is a whole host of small businesses attached to nightclubs, not to mention the traders who service the after-hours crowd in local fare, that would be affected by this malicious rule.

What Harapan is doing is destroying part of the culture of this country. Big City culture and what they want to do is to turn it into what some parts of this country are. Remember this day, because no matter what some people say about closing hours in the West, what we have here are sub rosa moves by the Islamist to slowly impose hegemony, Harapan style. This is just the beginning.

Who knows what the following year will bring in the permutations of Malay power. Frogs jumping, political opponents having lunch, internecine conflicts among Malay brokers in the major parties.

In this climate, do you blame people for feeling jaded and thinking that nothing changes?

I have two hopes for the new year. The first that young people discover the power they wield. And the second that the people who supported Harapan pressure the government so it does not become another BN.

Have a productive new year, Malaysia, whoever you are.

S THAYAPARAN is Commander (Rtd) of the Royal Malaysian Navy.

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.

5 thoughts on “A neo-BN New Year

  1. Thank Thaya and God/god (in that order) that the good Commander did not inflict his favourite overused word “poobah” on us in this piece – a reference that must sail several feet over the heads of his uneducated, semi-literate Cinabeng “readership” at Malaysiakini.

    Yet, he is still a master of the unfounded assertion:

    “First, they would recognise the Unified Examination Certificate (UEC). Then they would do away with Malay-only institutions. They would recognise the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (Icerd) for instance”.

    And what would happen if they did?

    What, exactly, changes for the better?

    “Uhhhhhhh, everything, mah!”

    Someone needs to define that, before regurgitating these as self-evident truisms; they are not.

    You need to persuade people (like, all of them) in advance that Icerd is a good thing, not write long lamentations later based on the assumed inevitability of that fact.

    Sounds like hard work; indeed a lot harder than writing poobah-laced articles for online portals with captive audiences.

    • @sthon, Melayu has more to loose in this land of the Welayu. If you cannot figure this out, your land does deserve to layu. Tun Dr is 93. He need not see much of this world. But, you might get to see how Melayu would layu more.

  2. “Yet, he is still a master of the unfounded assertion:”

    Uh-huh and you;re a master at the mendacious cherry pick.

    The preceding para – Firstly, why doesn’t someone give Azly Rahman a job sorting this mess out, but more importantly, if Bersatu and Harapan have the political will to slowly remove the tongkat and change the education system, they would make some good faith gestures. – sets the context.

    Context is important to honorable people but not you of course, a seasoned apologist for whatever Octo is offering up.

    So, if the don’t spook the Malays crowd were not just invested in polemics but actual policy , they would make some good faith gestures like , recognizing the UEC, doing away with Malay only institutions and ratifying ICERD because there was nothing said in the BERSATU meet up which the the grand poohbah has not said before in UMNO meet ups.

    And really, the only people who need to persuade the Malays are their political leaders egged on by the base that voted for them.

    Cretins who post on the comment sections on social media vilifying those who actually attempt to contribute to the change that some people wanted by expressing their beliefs on news portals slowly turning into the Pravda of Harapan are exactly the kind of douches that the Commander was warning about.

  3. Yup, Conrad i agree with your assertion about Malay political pschodynamics (polemics). There is certainly no new narrative coming outta Old Men, so- called Malay – which at the drop of a sarong, morph into fundamentalist Muslim – intellectual masturbators or even young Turks (with no apologies to Erdogan).

    The Ketuanan Crap in all it’s guises (glory-holes) is set in brittle stone foremost by an unrepentant Octo, who is unapologetic about his 60 plus year opus – called The Malay Dilemma.

    Otoh, i feel that as “Nons”, we shouldn’t be drawn into their long drawn out confusion of ‘What is a Malay?’ It would seem that ‘choice’ is a difficult concept to grasp. Parochialism is much easier. It’s not just ‘Feudalism’ it is also the inability to accept delayed gratification, to develop self-dignity through integrity and hard-work, self worth, convergent and divergent thinking processes and other significant cultural mores.

    Perhaps ‘The Paradox of Choice’ as developed by psychologist Barry Schwartz applies especially to them: “After millions of years of survival based on simple distinctions, it may be simply be that we are biologically unprepared for the number of choices we face in the modern world.”

    UMNOb, PAS, PPBM, PKR, Berjasa dll – headache lah!!

    Among the Ketuans it’s their destiny to ketok all comers, including – and especially – their Own. ICERD to them is an anomaly. UEC is about their failure of providing holistic education and thus embarrassment thereof. It is never about Economics per se – but Supremacy in Inadequacy.

    In actual fact the fault lies with PH ‘strategists’ who are all heads without tails. They did not ‘Prime’.. Most of the protests come from herder mentalities.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.