PD voter files for review of Danyal’s resignation, seeks to stop by-election


PD voter files for review of Danyal’s resignation, seeks to stop by-election

by Hafiz Yatim@www.malaysiakini.com

A Port Dickson voter filed a judicial review application at the Kuala Lumpur High Court yesterday to challenge the decision by his constituency’s outgoing MP Danyal Balagopal Abdullah (photo) to vacate the seat, as well as the calling of a by-election in the constituency next month.

Rosmadi Mohd Kassim, 56, named Danyal and the Election Commission (EC) as respondents in the application filed by law firm Raja Riza and Associates.

Rosmadi, who is a registered voter in Port Dickson, asked leave of the High Court to declare Danyal’s resignation invalid and therefore null and void. He also requested leave for a certiorari to quash the EC’s notice dated Sept 20 to hold the by-election.

Rosmadi is seeking a declaration that the EC’s decision to announce that the seat is vacant is wrong by law, as well as an injunction to stop the commission from holding the by-election on October 13. The hearing for leave has been fixed on October 2.

Image result for Anwar Ibrahim

In his application, Rosmadi said he had lodged a police report on September 24 regarding Danyal’s resignation. He then filed the judicial review application on the grounds that Danyal had violated the oath he took as an MP on July 16, when on September 12, the incumbent stated his reason for resignation as paving the way for incoming PKR president Anwar Ibrahim.

This, Rosmadi said, showed that Danyal favoured his loyalty to Anwar over Malaysians and a betrayal of Port Dickson voters’ trust, as the former navy man was not a bankrupt or physically incapacitated from doing his job as an MP.

The voter added that Danyal’s election promises had resulted in him winning the seat with a 17,710 majority against the PAS and BN candidate.

“Danyal’s resignation is not bona fide and against the provision of the Federal Constitution, as it is politically motivated and against public policy,” he said in the application.

“Article 51 of the Federal Constitution gives an MP the opportunity to relinquish his post, but it should be balanced by public interests,” he said, adding that such resignation should not be a political strategy, as it would destroy the democratic institution.

Rosmadi said that if Danyal is not interested to be a candidate then he should not have contested in the last general election.

He also alleged that the EC violated the statutory duty of its formation, as it should determine if the MP’s resignation is constitutional or not, before declaring the seat vacant and calling for a by-election. Rosmadi claimed EC failed to investigate whether Danyal’s resignation is in line with the constitutional provisions and is valid. Hence, he further alleged, Danyal’s resignation to pave the way for Anwar to be an MP and then be the PM is wrong in law and that the EC acted ultra vires to declare the vacancy and call for the by-election.

“Hence there is a prima facie case, for this judicial review application, as it is not an abuse of the court process,” said theapplicant, adding that if the injunction and his application is allowed, it would save huge costs in running a by-election.

5 thoughts on “PD voter files for review of Danyal’s resignation, seeks to stop by-election

  1. This will be a test case.If it is upheld, it could put an end to by-election as a route to becoming MP and a Minister. The next route via Dewan Negara should also be stopped. In future all Cabinet posts should be held by MPs of the winning party or coalition. By election should be allowed only under clear guidelines.–Din Merican.

  2. Should stop this mockery of Democracy with immediate full stop for better future under this new government. Wasting millions of taxpayers money without any valid reason just because arrogance of PKR. Those millions spent on by-election could be better used for some valid and justifiable reasons. After losing so much wealth to the robbers of UMNO, why do we have to undergo this new twist intentionally created by PKR? Stupid and arrogance with power craze has no borders and limitations. Stop the rot now!

  3. DSAI have to cross two obstacles to achieve the objective. Should the court are not taking the correct middle path, then it will be creating a sullen precedent for her future sojourn. A good test case for all who care to see the real new Malaysian Malaysia are walking in a correct path way forward into the future.

  4. To begin with, a Minister should have been directly elected by the people first before he is made a Minister. Making someone a senator in order to appoint him as Minister is a backdoor method undercutting democratic norms. Such a Minister lacks public endorsement and self credibility. A by-election should be created for such a person to contest and win before he is appointed a Minister. Alternatively he can be made a Minister on condition that he contests a by-election within 6 months upon assuming office.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.