Anwar family’s credibility gap is troubling

September 19, 2018

Anwar family’s credibility gap is troubling

by Terence Netto
A perception of nepotism would still be justified even if the reformasi movement, triggered by Anwar’s travails 20 years ago, had not had as its rallying cry the demand to end the corruption, cronyism and nepotism then plaguing the nation from UMNO-BN’s misrule.


COMMENT | The danger of choosing relatives of an iconic leader to deputise for him when he faces legal trammels imposed by the powers that be is that the surrogates are soon apt to think they are where they are by merit rather than presumption.

This is the situation of Dr Wan Azizah Wan Ismail, the PKR leader who has just added petulance to a lengthening list of her demerits, both as party leader and as Deputy Prime Minister.

“Is there a problem? I thought we were voted by the rakyat (people),” was Wan Azizah’s disingenuous reply when questioned by reporters on the possibility of the public perceiving the presence in Parliament of her, daughter Nurul Izzah and – should he win in Port Dickson – husband Anwar Ibrahim as rank nepotism.

A perception of nepotism would still be justified even if the reformasi movement, triggered by Anwar’s travails 20 years ago, had not had as its rallying cry the demand to end the corruption, cronyism and nepotism then plaguing the nation from UMNO-BN’s misrule.

Because the movement had made it its clarion call to combat these three scourges of the polity, it is incumbent upon the Pied Piper of the movement (Anwar) and the one who deputised as leader while Anwar was in prison to see to it that such faults as the reformasi movement decried then are not replicated now, when the reform-seekers have become the government.

That’s not all the perceptual burden that has to be avoided.As recently as last year, in an interview with Al Jazeera, Wan Azizah had described her part as that of a “seat warmer”. Clearly, she meant that her withdrawal from the political arena would follow upon the release of Anwar from jail and his return to the legislative fray.

A royal pardon for Anwar in May removed one hindrance to his return; his election unopposed to the PKR top post last month has taken care of the other. But Azizah is not budging from her occupation of the Pandan parliamentary seat she won in GE-14.

Image result for nurul izzah anwar 2018

Neither is Nurul Izzah (photo, above) from Anwar’s traditional stronghold of Permatang Pauh, to which she fled from Lembah Pantai, her seat for two parliamentary terms from 2008.

Things have to be paved and peril-free for the First Family, small matter if that aids the public perception that the family is being granted exceptions to the norm.

The decision of the newly-elected PKR MP for Port Dickson, Danyal Balagopal Abdullah, to quit his seat to allow Anwar to contest en route to becoming the eighth prime minister of Malaysia is being lauded as noble sacrifice. Perhaps we now know why Anwar recently publicly noted that there maybe more Indian Malaysians in PKR than in MIC: The ethnic group are easy sacrificial meat.

He may think that the ability to gyrate to the rhythms and mime the songs of Tamil movies should suffice as a demonstration of solidarity with the concerns of this demographic.Suffice that members of the First Family have become PKR royalty, exempt from the ordinary criteria of selection and scrutiny.

The fact that the party has become dysfunctional as a democratic entity, its factional strife so obvious that it makes liars of those attempting to deny the reality, is not allowed to redound to the discredit of the First Family.

Mendacity is the default option of those for whom the acquisition of power overrides other chastening considerations.In years past Anwar used to be fond on the hustings of quoting Mahatma Gandhi’s “What is morally right cannot be politically wrong, and what is politically correct must not be morally wrong,” to project his concern that the devices of politics be congruent with the imperatives of morality.

In recent months, the gulf between the two – his morality and his politics – has opened up wide enough for many to think that what has happened to Turkey’s Recep Tayyip Erdogan is occurring to Anwar.

TERENCE NETTO has been a journalist for more than four decades. A sobering discovery has been that those who protest the loudest tend to replicate the faults they revile in others.

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.


4 thoughts on “Anwar family’s credibility gap is troubling

  1. Some say Anwar is the person who got the Pakatan together. I differ, but would say it is Kak Wan and Nurul who gets this big ego Pakatan together.
    After all, Anwar is in jail longer than he serves as a MP.

    It is the daughter and wife that truly gave the nation hope. They both are true statesmen that deserve our respect. After Tun Dr, it will still be Kak Wan and Nurul who could move this nation forward.

    If one fears Anwar would become Erdogan, one should consider putting Nurul into higher place to put the moral compass of her father back into place.

    Nurul as the next PM!!!

  2. Allow room for the leaders to work through the system. The voters must ensure that strong institutions are place to allow leaders to come and go. Just for a moment study the countries that are doing ok and try to emulate their strong points.
    We need to do this quickly because before you know it our population would hit that magic figure of 70 million.

  3. The royal pardoned nullified Anwar Ibrahim’s Reformasi agenda. Anwar Ibrahim and family no have more pressing issues to work and his leadership no longer relevant.

  4. It’s nobody’s right to suggest of any power in the government. Ballot box decides one’s fate. Anwar is definitely not relevant to our present times. May be he was, at the time when he was charged Sodomy 1 because many sympathised and shouted for ‘REFORMATION” out of the feelings against Mahathir then. That was almost 20 years ago and now the same voices have turned against Anwar.

    Katasayang suggested to look for Nurul who is a PM’s material rather than wasting time on Anwar. The same was said as Anwar the future PM but the same voices which drumed the ears for Anwar 20 years ago have now become MUTE. Do you see the reaction of the same supporters lending a deaf year today? Based on this, time and tide for Nurul or her mother would tell according the changing world of the future generation.

    About 5 decades ago, TIME MAGAZINE, an international newsmaker of those years projected in its front page 2 portraits of Musa Hitam and Tengku Razaleigh to watch as the future Prime Ministers of Malaysia after the tenure of Tun Abdul Razak. Do you see the fate of the 2 leaders now, though Musa Hitam was almost there but Kuli never had a chance to lead his party though he was so obsessive of his principles till today.

    The right to be PM is not for Anwar or his Party PKR entering a contract with PH to decide. Anwar has lost his relevancy and outdated in his political acumen. His thinking of he is the rightful PM after Tun and not DPM is being power crazy and senseless talking. Can you suggest what good of a person who has spent more than half his political life in prison serving his sodomy 1 and 2 convictions and at the same time lost touch of the outside world? PD by election tide may favor him but that doesn’t mean he must be given the PM’s post after the tenure of Tun’s office.

Leave a Reply to Kente Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.