A new national car–Massaging Someone’s ego? Just rethink, please

August 2, 2018

A new national car–Massaging Someone’s ego? Just rethink, please

by T K Chua


Don’t let another generation of Malaysians undergo the ordeal of overpriced cars of hopeless quality.

Related image


What has happened to all the Pakatan Harapan politicians who were so good at saying all the right things before the election but are now blind, deaf and dumb to all the wrong things being proposed and done?

Why is it that no one of substance has talked about the third national car project so far? Are we really going to toy with this “adventure” again with tariff and non-tariff restrictions as proposed?

Look, a whole generation of Malaysians has grown up and grown old using overpriced cars of hopeless quality. I don’t think another generation of Malaysians should undergo the same ordeal again.

I get it: the car industry is a conduit to engineering prowess and stardom, so the argument goes. But what did we get for ourselves in the past few decades? A perpetually protected industry saddled with gross inefficiency which burdened the consumers to the hilt.

I believe some form of protection may be necessary to support an “infant” industry. However, to be effective such protection must have an unequivocal time frame for its removal. Otherwise, it is just another “rent seeking” and profiteering venture, nothing else.

Image result for A New National Car for Malaysia?

Let’s not kid ourselves: when “protected industries” gain, the consumers lose – as simple as that.

The Koreans started their car industry around the same time as Malaysia’s Proton. They protected their car market and so did we. After 30 years, I think we know the difference between us and Korea.

Now we are contemplating protecting our car market again! Well, protecting our market to build up the capacity to compete is very different from protecting our market to “skin” the consumers.

Image result for Hyundai Motors

Proton made enormous amounts of money in its heydays through protectionism. But where are its engineering prowess, research and development capability and the capacity to compete?

Korea had the same protectionism as we did but with one exception: they knew how to use the window of opportunity to build better cars to compete domestically and to penetrate the foreign markets. Look at the Korean car industry today and look at ours.

“Timeless” protection for any industry is a recipe for disaster; there is no record of a success story on this.

I think it is a little too late in the day for us to be fixated with the car industry. However, this does not mean we cannot excel in other fields.

Let’s not be overambitious and gung-ho in our “can do” attitude. When the chief justice and judges have to clean toilets and when the law minister must personally look at the toilet cleaning contract, I think we still have a long way to go before attaining professionalism and engineering prowess.

I apologise if I have hurt the feelings of Malaysians in general. But I think we are still very much a “chinchai” country.

TK Chua is an FMT reader.

The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.

8 thoughts on “A new national car–Massaging Someone’s ego? Just rethink, please

  1. I am thinking we are looking to produce a solar powered car.. that could be some national car! Like to still see what TDM has in plan.

  2. Hi Din i sent yr greetings to Qadeer of Car n Co.
    Lets wait to see what TDM has in mind – but we dont want another Proton like project thats for sure.

    Dr. M will get his way, since there is no one in his PH coalition who will raise any objections. Sorry if I am cynical. This is because they are happy to have become Menteris and Timbalan Menteris. Anwar will not pick fight now. He is already next in line and will just wait his turn. Aren’t all politicians the same; they are after power and status.–Din Merican

    ps. thanks for sending my wishes to Qadeer Ahmad. He is a special guy to me.His late father too was an extraordinary man.

  3. There is no end to this type of talk with the politicians, be they be from UMNO Barisan or PH ministers who were given the new mandate. When they have got the ministerial posts, they become “yes” men to their boss. It’s happening now in many issues which have been brought to light but they stay uncommitted for fear of getting brickbats from their boss or public.

    True in your comparison to Koreans who have advanced many folds in their technological advancement when compared to Malaysia during the same pace. When will our politicians become more open to changes rather than fooling the rakyat with so many promises during the election campaigns?

  4. We need to build a nation state, not another nation car that would, without any doubt, shame and fail us again.
    ” My way” is Blind !

    Stop wasting Rakyats time and money. It had not worked for Malaysia and will never work again. It is capital intensive.

    We just do not have the market and economic of scale to venture into it again. It is a very competitive foreign market out there that also involved state of art technical skill and innovation in terms of research , production, design and quality of the car and its engine, to survive and sustain profits.

    Malaysia has lost its way !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.