Pakatan Harapan: Get Going or You will be Trounced in GE-14

June 29, 2017

Pakatan Harapan: Get Going or You will be Trounced in GE-14

by Wan Saiful Wan Jan

Image result for Mahathir and Anwar

Mahathir and Anwar–The Harapans for Pakatan Harapan

The Opposition coalition has to make some important decisions about leadership, especially in the run-up to the general election.

PAKATAN Harapan is amazingly creative in creating job titles. Chairman, President and Ketua Umum have been floated as potential titles for their top posts, all aimed at ensuring one person is above everybody else without putting any of their big shots below the president.

The person is Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. Despite being in prison, his letters and whispers still dictate how PKR decides. I cannot imagine how they will run a country. Every time a difficult question comes up in a Cabinet meeting, would they call for a coffee break while waiting for the postman to arrive?

They don’t seem to realise that, being in prison, Anwar’s own thought process would be easily influenced by what is conveyed to him and how the person visiting him explains it to him. The letters that he writes cannot possibly be based on a holistic consideration of all options and consequences.

Anwar’s camp in PKR says that if they win, they would ensure Anwar gets a royal pardon so that he becomes Prime Minister.

This is an extraordinary suggestion because the power to pardon belongs to our Rulers. No politicians in their rightful mind would ever assume that they could muscle over our Rulers, giving instructions just like that.

Luckily, over the weekend, Anwar declared he is not offering himself to be the prime minister candidate any more. This is a welcome deve­lopment because even those who do not support Pakatan are growing tired of their drama.

The stumbling block in Pakatan is PKR, because they are severely divided about Anwar’s future role, and Anwar’s camp in PKR feels insecure. However, Anwar’s latest announcement should allow PKR to move on.

Anwar’s camp in PKR must take the announcement as a call to stop naming him as the potential Prime Minister. Although Anwar was vague when saying he is “not offering” himself, they should not persuade him to change his mind, or plan for an interim Prime Minister who will pass the seat to Anwar later.

This should be made a definitive closure. Otherwise, that statement was nothing but a deception. I also urge Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad to follow suit. But he should do more than Anwar. He should declare that he, too, is not interested in becoming Prime Minister again, and he will also not contest in GE14.

That would assuage Anwar’s camp and other critics in Pakatan. Pakatan must actively consider na­ming someone from their younger generation as prime minister. Wan Azizah has said she does not feel she is the best person for the post.

She is right. She is not. There are others who could do the job better. She should recuse herself too, and this will prevent allegations that Anwar is Prime Minister candidate by proxy.

Instead, Pakatan should name someone younger. This could be a game changer because others will immediately be under pressure to consider a different new line-up too. But the person should be from PKR, because Anwar’s camp will never accept PKR losing the Pime Minister candidacy.

Image result for Azmin Ali

It is time for Azmin Ali to take PKR and revitalise its political organization. Wan Azizah should retire from being Anwar Ibrahim’s proxy.

I have never had the chance to talk to Datuk Seri Mohamad Azmin Ali (above) personally, so my judgment may well be wrong here. But from afar, he seems to be the most obvious candidate from PKR. Despite all the ruckus between PAS and all the Pakatan parties, he has proven that he can hold the coalition together in Selangor.

Considering all the odds, this is no easy feat. Even Dr Mahathir and Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin could not persuade PAS to remain in Pakatan. And he is also one of the very few with administrative experience.

Adding names likes Datuk Seri Mukhriz Mahathir, Nurul Izzah Anwar and Salahuddin Ayob to the top line-up would make the election even more exciting.

Anwar, however, did not name a successor. This will likely encourage Anwar’s camp in PKR to work harder to block Azmin, because they have never fully trusted him. Anwar himself is partly to blame here. He should have endorsed a credible successor. Otherwise, Anwar and his camp in PKR remain the biggest stumbling block for Pakatan’s stability.

Pakatan should treat the issue of coalition leadership as separate from the Prime Minister candidate. I cannot imagine Wan Azizah being an effective chairman in a meeting attended by Dr Mahathir and Muh­yid­din.

These two figures are far more experienced than she. Yes, she has sacrificed a lot for Pakatan’s struggle. But now is the time for her and her family to make the most meaningful sacrifice for the cause, which is to give PKR and Pakatan the freedom to flourish.

Pakatan needs a chairman who can facilitate decision-making without having to wait for notes from Sungai Buloh prison. Dr Mahathir is the best person for that. After two decades of chairing Barisan Nasional, is there anyone more experienced than Dr Mahathir in chairing a coalition of political parties?

But if Dr Mahathir becomes chair­­man, it is only logical that Muhyiddin could not become president because that would be domination by one party. Muhyiddin’s expertise is in strategising for elections. He has led UMNO and Barisan Nasional to victory in so many successful general elections and by-elections. He is more valuable to Pakatan if he leads their electioneering machinery, regard­less of the title given to him.

Since their target is to defeat UMNO, there really is no one in Pakatan more knowledgeable than Muhyiddin about UMNO’s strategies, dirty tricks, and tactics.

It does not matter which party you or I support. It is tiring to watch the indecision of Anwar’s camp in PKR. It has become too much and has continued for too long.Since Anwar has opened the door, for goodness sake, PKR, please move on.

Wan Saiful Wan Jan is chief executive of the Institute for Democracy and Economic Affairs ( The views expressed here are entirely the writer’s own.

9 thoughts on “Pakatan Harapan: Get Going or You will be Trounced in GE-14

  1. To say that lets win the GE first then decide on the PM is downright stupid.

    Which country, ancient or modern, democratic or dictatorial, practices that?

    If PH, (or indeed any future morph), cannot settle on the PM designate going into any GE then it deserves to lose.

    Actually PH at the moment is having too many cooks but no chef.

    Whether you hate or trust Mahathir or not, looks like he is the best bet as far as GE14 is concerned. The real problem, I think, is his deputy, whether in PH or the Cabinet.

    The person who should really sacrifice or give way is Muhyiddin. He cannot or cannot even be seen as Mahathir’s deputy. The deputy has to come from PKR who sees itself as the originator, (perhaps even the “soul”), of “Reformasi” and therefore deserves to be in the forefront with or without Anwar.

    It is beneath Muhyiddin’s stature to vie with all the young pugs from DAP or Amanah for a 2nd or 3rd liners position in PH or the Cabinet.

  2. Must also have a progressive populist election manifesto that will win votes. Jeremy Corbyn showed the way in Britain recently.

    For lower income voters, must emphasise the disastrous inflationary forces released by MO1’s mismanagement of the nation’s finances.
    Must also make them understand that more and more cutbacks will be forthcoming to public services such as health, education and so on (as the pressure of public debt deepens).

    • Pakatan must be able put the massage across for the common folks to understand. How prices of everyday items have incresed. How removing the subsidies have contributed to the high cost of living. How our money have been siphoned out and used for gambling in casinos, for lavish parties, for private yacht and airplanes, for buying luxury apartments, for starting a career in movie production. The hooha created by the lapdogs re the DOJ is only for local consumption.

  3. Pakatan Harapan needs to gets its act together and march to Putrajaya through GE14. Pakatan Rakyat had a good framework with the Presidential Council. Selangor and Penang have shown the way ahead. Don’t be goaded by BN to name a target for them to attack. Be democratic and see which party can win the most support. Remember, the fight is with UMNO and their hanger-on.

  4. PH can win GE-14? C’mon folks, get real! Puerility has limits, or perhaps sanity is over rated.

    Cervantes authored “The Ingenious Nobleman Mister Quixote of La Mancha” for this reason. “Once upon a time, in a land called Malusia..”

    Ole’ Blue Eyes is still the version i like best, even if Richard Kiley sang it with more passion for the divine Sophia Loren, in ‘The Man from La Mancha’:

    • They said Trump would never win. Strange thing happened. Never say never, despite how slim the chances be.

    • Far be it, that i don’t have hope, LaMoy.
      But i’d rather face the truth than be disappointed by a disparate bunch of desperadoes who can’t get their act together. Unless PH truly understands the magnitude of their task, set a real or substantive agenda and stop diddling with their groin (syiok sendiri), they don’t have a hope in hell.

      As Leonard Cohen, my favorite eclectic troubadour foresaw:

    • I’ve long learned never say never about anything. We can have our little dreams, but what we want and what we get are often at odds. I think Trump is a nut job and an Antichrist, but you have people like Shiou who think he is the Second Coming of Christ and a world savior, saving the world from all the leftists.

  5. Bersatu is not fighting for reform, they are fighting to preserve entitlements being jeopardised by Najib’s UMNO. PH delimma is still our national debate about entitlement even after over 40 years of NEP.

    Mahatir solution was crude wrecking ball that brought it to this point. Now the very same ideas and type of people, still want to argue they should lead and better their wrecking ball. It simply will not work no matter how they argue their wrecking ball has some merit.

    With great power come greater responsibility. If you failed, messed up, someone else gets the next crack, the same people cannot become surgeons with scalpel.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s