Cambodia: Time for the United States to cancel its 1970 Dirty Debt


April 16, 2017

Cambodia: Time for the United States to cancel its 1970  Dirty Debt

by Kongkea Chhoeun@www.eastasiaforum,org

The Cambodian government has once again called on the United States to cancel its US$500 million debt. In the 1970s, the Cambodian government borrowed about US$270 million to purchase food supplies. This debt was never repaid and has now swollen to US$500 million. This is equivalent to 15 per cent of Cambodia’s 2016 national budget and about half the total aid the country has received from the United States since the peace settlement of 1991.

Image result for cambodia today

 

Cambodia and the United States have been negotiating the debt since 1995 but have failed to come close to an agreement. The latest appeal by Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen likely stems from the Cambodian People’s Party’s (CPP) anxiety about its popular support ahead of the 2017 local government election. By exploiting public sentiment in support of debt cancellation, the CPP can position itself as the champion of the Cambodian people.

Image result for US-Cambodia relations

Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger : The Bombers of Cambodia–Time for the US to atone for their criminality

But the call also has merit. The Cambodian government has consistently argued that this is ‘dirty’ debt. It maintains that the Lon Nol government, which came to power in March 1970 through a US-backed coup, borrowed the funds to buy weapons that were used against the Khmer Rouge in the civil war of the early 1970s. The CPP also argues that Cambodia deserves debt forgiveness because of illegal bombing carried out by the United States from March 1969 until August 1973.

During this period, US warplanes dropped more than 500,000 tons of explosives on Cambodian villages along the Cambodia–Vietnam and Cambodia–Lao borders. Up to 500,000 lives were consequently lost. Moreover, the secret bombing campaigns and the US-supported coup created the conditions for the rise of the genocidal Khmer Rouge regime that killed almost 2 million Cambodians between 1975 and 1979.

Image result for US-Cambodia relations

Former US Secretary of State John Kerry and US Ambassador to Cambodia William Heidt

The United States has consistently refused to completely cancel the debt but has long indicated that it is willing to negotiate a partial cancellation. US Ambassador to Cambodia William Heidt was recently quoted in local press as saying that the United States has, ‘never seriously discussed or considered cancelling the debt’ but is willing to ‘[work] out a deal that works for both sides’.

The deal that the United States has in mind is no doubt similar to the one it struck with Vietnam in 2000. That year, the United States enacted a repayment-for-assistance program after Vietnam signed a bilateral agreement in 1997 and resumed making scheduled payments of its debt. The US Congress created the Vietnam Education Foundation, into which is channelled about 40 per cent of Vietnam’s total debt payments to the United States. The Foundation provides opportunities for Vietnamese nationals to pursue graduate and post-graduate studies in the United States and for US citizens to teach in Vietnam.

It is certainly in US interests to settle the Cambodian debt as soon as possible. Cambodia has drawn closer and closer to China over the last two decades. As a small, poor and insecure state surrounded by two bigger, historical enemies, Cambodia needs China as insurance against Vietnam and Thailand. More importantly, Cambodia’s political regime increasingly depends on China for foreign capital to sustain the economic performance needed to maintain its political legitimacy. Foreign direct investment from China reached US$857 million in 2015 or roughly 61.1 per cent of total FDI. Chinese aid to Cambodia amounted to US$320 million in 2015 or roughly 30 per cent of total aid received.

Cambodia’s closer links with China benefit China’s strategic interests too. Cambodia closed Taiwan’s representative office in Phnom Penh in 1997. In 2010, Cambodia deported 20 Uyghur nationals and Chinese citizens to China. In July 2012, Cambodia prevented ASEAN from issuing a joint statement over the South China Sea issue. Once again in July 2016, Cambodia blocked any reference in an ASEAN statement to a UN-backed court’s ruling against Beijing’s claims to the South China Sea.

Data from the Council for the Development of Cambodia shows that the United States has granted US$1.13 billion to Cambodia since 1992. But no matter how much aid the United States has already generously given to improve the lives of Cambodians since the early 1990s, if the United States wants to regain influence in Cambodia, it needs to forgive the debt.

It is unclear why a compromise similar to the US–Vietnam deal has not been struck between the United States and Cambodia. In any case, Cambodia appears to bear little penalty for not repaying its debt. It can access the foreign capital it needs, mainly from China. It also borrows from the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank.

Given this, even partial repayment from Cambodia is unlikely. So the logical step forward is for the United States to write off the debt. But this is unlikely, especially under the Trump administration. The result will be to push Cambodia deeper into China’s orbit.

Kongkea Chhoeun is a PhD candidate at the Crawford School of Public Policy, The Australian National University.

 

2 thoughts on “Cambodia: Time for the United States to cancel its 1970 Dirty Debt

  1. I’m at a loss for words why Trump is pushing US Ambassador to Cambodia William Heidt to bring up this ‘dirty’ and ‘blood stained’ debt. Regardless of the shaky moral basis, Heidt puts pressures on Cambodia to pay the debt by threatening to ask the International Monetary Fund to downgrade its creditworthiness and its capacity to access international capital. But Cambodia’s position with regards to the debt issue will not be affected by US pressure as it has earned strategic trust and support from China. So, what’s the point?

    Cambodia-US relations have been improved remarkably since 2010 under Obama, and are better than at any time in the past four decades of ties, which were marred by distrust and confrontation. Bilateral economic and educational cooperation has increased over the years despite political and strategic differences. The US is the biggest market for Cambodia’s clothes, the country’s main export industry. Both sides should focus more on common interests and cooperation while gradually narrowing down their differences. Why is Trump bringing up this ‘dirty’ debt again? The US’ engagement with ASEAN may be affected if the bilateral US-Cambodia relationship continues to deteriorate to become confrontational.

    There are examples of US debt forgiveness. Washington forgave debts to Vietnam in 1997, Bosnia-Herzegovina in 1999, Yugoslavia in 2002 and Iraq in 2004. Why is Cambodia not on the list of countries deserving debt forgiveness? In 2000, the US and Vietnam agreed to convert the war debt into a Vietnam education exchange fund. This model for debt recycling or a debt-swap agreement between the US and Vietnam should be applicable to Cambodia as well. If Trump has any political sense he should have his men to negotiate with Cambodia to explore common ground to resolve the long-standing debt issue, which may be solved by reaching an agreement on converting the debt into a development program or humanitarian assistance to Cambodia.

    Ivanka, talk some sense into your blockhead daddy!

    • LaMoy,

      The United States, in my view, should compensate Cambodia for causing untold hardships on Cambodians during the Vietnam War and for turning a blind eye to the genocide. The United States also supported the Khmer Rouge at the United Nations and the CIA was responsible for the overthrow of Norodom Sihanouk in 1970 which threw the country into a state of chaos. It is time for the Trump Administration todeal with this ugly ‘dirty’debt issue intelligently and finally bring closure to the tragedy. The Cambodian people have not forgotten this display of American arrogance of power.–Din Merican

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s