Speaker Pandikar Amin (NOT)Mulia gets notice of court action on tabling of Act 355

April 5, 2017

Speaker Pandikar Amin (NOT) Mulia gets notice of court action on tabling of Act 355

by Adrian Wong@www.malaysiakini.com

Image result for Tawfik Ismail

Civil Society Activist

Mr. Mohamed Tawfik Ismail, the son of former Deputy Prime Minister Dr Ismail Abdul Rahman, expects PAS not to table the controversial proposed amendments to the Syariah Courts (Criminal Jurisdiction) Act 1965 in Parliament tomorrow.

This comes with him having served an originating summons to Dewan Rakyat Speaker Pandikar Amin Mulia, to make the entire tabling of the amendment to be sub judice.

“We do not expect the Act 355 amendment to be on the order paper for tomorrow,” Tawfik told reporters after serving the summons he obtained from the High Court, which he served on the speaker of the House.

His solicitor, Mansoor Saat, who was also present, explained that this would be so because the Speaker had set precedents in past matters that the issue of sub-judice would set in if a matter before the House is taken to court.

“Following the precedents in some other cases, similar with this issue, the amendments should not go into the Dewan Rakyat for the tabling,” Mansoor added.

Tawfik filed the originating summons in the High Court in Kuala Lumpur last Friday, to seek a declaration that the proposed Act 355 amendments were unconstitutional.

Tawfik explained at the press conference today that the move to table the amendments without the Malay rulers or Conference of Rulers’ giving the go-ahead would deem them unconstitutional. This is because the nine Malay rulers also head Islamic matters in their respective states.

“This move is taken to defend the country and the Federal Constitution. The Yang di-Pertuan Agong also has to defend the rule of law.

“For me, the court should make several declarations so that the amendments would not cause problems in the people’s thinking,” Tawfik said, adding that the application was filed in court last Friday and copies were served today to Pandikar (photo) and the Dewan Rakyat secretary.

He added that he was acting urgently on this matter, because Deputy Prime Minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi had said that PAS President Abdul Hadi Awang would be able to table the amendments on the last day of the Parliament sitting, which is tomorrow.

He said this was something of natural concern, and “we do not think that the proper procedures have been followed in Parliament”.

‘Must always abide by the constitution’

Tawfik added that he had sent several letters on the matter, and even to the Keeper of the Rulers Seal to ascertain if the Malay rulers had given their approval to the controversial bill or otherwise.

“We already sent another notice to remind the ‘Speaker last week, and he didn’t respond. So we have no choice but serve the originating summons today.

“We wrote to the rulers before the Rulers’ Conference in March. And the amendments did not get any acknowledgement of approval from them.We are also concerned because the government too wanted to table its own bill on the same basis. But if the government did not have the consent of the rulers, then how? We must always abide by the constitution,” he said.


Najib Razak is playing with Islamic Fire and will be burnt politically

“I hope the Prime Minister (Najib Abdul Razak) feels the same on this. Maybe, due to political reasons, he has been caught. If Abdul Hadi does it the proper way, by getting the rulers first of all to agree, then nobody would have an issue of its constitutionality. We are not attacking the philosophy behind this bill, because it is not religious as far as I am concerned. This concerns a matter of rule of law,” Tawfik explained.


8 thoughts on “Speaker Pandikar Amin (NOT)Mulia gets notice of court action on tabling of Act 355

  1. Islamist do not care for any law, rule, reason or even facts and reality but the ones they want.

    Muslim must admit, Islam, or “din”, the way of life, because its rules are so much and personally, publicly, is a weapon, a public power weapon distributed to those who read and preach it’s text. If they think wide ownership of guns is a bad idea, how is having the public power-weapon of unquestionable faith widely distributed a good idea?

  2. This should be interesting.

    If indeed Tawfik is right, i.e. the Conference of Rulers’ prerequisite consent is needed, then Parliament, (organically all the MPs), by its very act of itself not stopping the Bill but in fact on the verge of presenting it is guilty of high treason against the Crown. It amounts to a usurpation by way of a deliberate encroachment on royal prerogative.

    The Keeper of the Rulers’ Seal should have convened an urgent Conference to discuss this very issue when it was learnt that PAS was putting in a private members’ Bill and at the very latest when the Government, which rules in the Rulers’ name, itself wanted to “take it over”

    What could be more serious a matter to the Heads of Islam in the country than a proposed amendment to a law which goes to the very fundamental rights and liberties of millions of loyal Muslim subjects?

    We hope the Rulers take a very serious view of this kind of unconstitutional behavior and become a litigating party in support of the originating summons filed by Tawfik, if this is jurisprudentially correct; if not, I am sure Constitutional lawyers can urgently advise the Rulers accordingly?

    • Wayne,

      Yes, indeed, Hadi is a narrow minded cleric and a failed politician whose agenda is Hudud. He is no where near the late Nik Aziz Nik Mat in terms of intellect. That makes Najib a greater fool since he blindly supports the PAS President, ignoring the fact that Malaysia is a plural society where people have freedom of worship. We cannot have two sets of laws, one for Muslims and another for non-Muslims, and that is why we have a secular constitution.in the first place. Anyway, since when there is Rule of Law in Malaysia? Our Rulers are powerless. Mahathir made sure of that and he also tamed the Judiciary to ensure the Executive Branch is the final arbiter of justice. Najib inherited the system so that change is now impossible. I welcome your comments.–Din Merican

  3. But then again, PAS, and even UMNO, can now say it was not their fault that the Bill cannot go any further. Un-Islamic or Anti-Islamic people are sabotaging it.

    They may actually come up smelling roses now when facing their Malay-Muslim constituents.

  4. Is this the same Speaker that wanted a private toilet in his office and recently rang up RM 1.4 mil for access road to his house?
    That’s why I call Amin (Not) Mulia. He is irresponsible and abusive of power. He is from Sabah UMNO.–Din Merican.

  5. Well, nothing makes sense anymore in Bolehland. Each morning I’ll wake up not to watch what’s on the local networks but what’s on CNN, BBC, Bloomberg, Australian Network and, sometimes, China’s CCTV. Our local networks are crap with a capital “C”. If only our rural folks have access to these networks, Al Jubor and Umno will be history in double-quick time. But, sadly, they don’t, so the brainwashing continues unabated.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.