Looking Back on Barack Obama

February 3, 2017

Looking Back on Barack Obama

Jeffrey Frankel*


*Jeffrey Frankel, a professor at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government, previously served as a member of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisers. He directs the Program in International Finance and Macroeconomics at the US National Bureau of Economic Research, where he is a member of the Business Cycle Dating Committee, the official US arbiter of recession and recovery.

Image result for Jeffrey Frankel

Any assessment of Barack Obama’s eight-year US presidency should start at the beginning: his first inauguration, on January 20, 2009. The US economy was in free-fall: financial markets had seized up, GDP was shrinking, and employment was plummeting, with some 800,000 jobs being lost each month. And two ill-conceived and badly executed foreign wars were underway.

In short, upon entering office, Obama confronted conditions more adverse than any incoming president had faced in many decades. True, Franklin D. Roosevelt inherited the Great Depression and Abraham Lincoln took office as the Civil War erupted. But who else entered the White House facing both an economic and a national-security crisis?

To tackle the economic crisis, Obama launched a fiscal stimulus and rescue programs for the financial system and the auto industry – policies that complemented and reinforced the US Federal Reserve’s aggressive and innovative monetary easing. Republicans nearly unanimously opposed the stimulus. And almost everybody was critical of the rescue programs, urging Obama either to nationalize the banks and auto companies or let them collapse.
Image result for Barack Obama
Citizen Obama–Let History be the Judge

Against all odds, the Obama administration made the middle path work. The recession ended in June 2009 – an achievement for which the administration did not get enough credit, despite the clarity of the turnaround. In the last quarter of 2008, economic output had declined by an astonishing 8.2% per annum. Yet, almost immediately after the stimulus program was implemented, the output decline and employment losses slowed sharply. The bottom came in June 2009, with output growth turning positive in the next quarter.

Net job creation followed early in 2010. Employment growth persisted for the remainder of Obama’s time in office, reaching record-breaking levels: the US economy added more than 15 million jobs during Obama’s remaining years. By the latter part of Obama’s second term, unemployment had fallen by half, to below 5%; wages were rising; and real median family incomes were finally increasing, by a record-high 5.2% in the most recently reported year, with lower-income groups benefiting from even higher gains.

True, the recovery was disappointingly long and slow. One reason was the depth and financial origins of the 2007-2008 crash. Another was the efforts of the Republicans, who secured a majority in Congress in 2010, to block further stimulus, even though more infrastructure spending and well-designed tax cuts were precisely what the US economy needed in 2011-2014. Republicans, it seems, support fiscal expansion only when they control the White House.

Obama managed two other major achievements before Republican obstructionism took hold: the Dodd-Frank financial reform bill and the Affordable Care Act (ACA, also known as “Obamacare”). Despite Republicans’ subsequent steps to weaken Dodd-Frank and the ACA, both reforms did much more good than most people realize. Dodd-Frank helped make a repeat of the 2007-2008 financial crisis less likely, and the ACA has given more than 20 million Americans access to health insurance while slowing the rise in overall health-care costs.

The two wars that Obama inherited were intractable. But he made the difficult decisions that led to the elimination of the instigator of the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, Osama bin Laden – a goal that his predecessor, George W. Bush, in his eagerness to invade Iraq, had lost interest in pursuing.

Image result for Trump quotes

Moreover, in 2015, just as the press began labeling him a lame duck, Obama achieved a string of foreign-policy successes – namely, a much-needed nuclear agreement with Iran, normalization of relations with Cuba, and agreement on the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP). He also helped to secure a global deal to fight climate change, particularly by first achieving a breakthrough with China.

President-elect Donald Trump, who takes over the presidency this month, faces far easier conditions than Obama. Nevertheless, he has announced plans to reverse most, if not all, of Obama’s achievements. The TPP, for example, is dead. And four years from now will probably be too late to revive it, because by then East Asian countries may have been drawn into a China-led trade grouping instead.

Image result for The President of Iran Quotes

In some cases, however, Trump will run into obstacles in translating his crowd-pleasing sound bites into reality. In repealing Obamacare, for example, Republicans are likely to be stymied by the absence of an alternative that does not take away the health insurance of 20 million Americans or raise health-care costs. Given this, they may end up making only minor substantive changes to the ACA and then slapping a new name on it – the analog of building a “beautiful” quarter-mile wall along the Mexican border to serve as a backdrop for photo opportunities.

 Trump’s promise to tear up the nuclear agreement with Iran is similarly out of touch with reality. Without the participation of America’s allies, re-imposing sanctions will have little impact, beyond spurring Iran to restart and even accelerate its nuclear program. That’s what North Korea did when Bush, upon taking office, essentially tore up the “agreed framework” with that country.

With Trump poised to make such imprudent decisions, will US voters hold him accountable? Bush made serious economic- and foreign-policy mistakes during his presidency, beginning in its early years, with predictable consequences for the economy, the federal budget, and national security. Although his poll numbers soared in his first term, they were far lower by the time he left office.

Conversely, Obama’s popularity sagged during much of his eight-year presidency. Yet he leaves office with substantially higher approval ratings than most presidents achieve – and far higher than Trump’s. The American public does, eventually, recognize the successes and failures of their leaders. Unfortunately, it sometimes takes a while.


7 thoughts on “Looking Back on Barack Obama

  1. Coming after George W. Bush and before Donald J. Trump, I am sure Barack Obama is going to look very good for future historians. Probably the one thing he will not be forgiven for by the American people is allowing the Democratic party to nominate Hillary Clinton.

    The system itself is broken and needs a reform movement. Until then, everyone who rides into the White House on a message of Hope, is doomed to disappoint. The new cabinet of soldiers and billionaires, is just more of the same. Bush brought the Decline of America. Obama presided over the Decline of America. Trump will now usher in the Fall of America.

    I say this with real sadness and shame, but to my view Trump exists because a great many Americans share his lack of integrity, decency and character. Trump has forced us to take a long hard look at who we are as a nation, and many, maybe most, of us don’t like what we see. From the greatest generation, proud and self-reliant, to the whiny generation longing for some strongman to save us from ourselves — in one lifetime. An incredible fall from grace and honor.

    • LaMoy,

      He came to power with Hope for change, but Washington DC, as I know it albeit long ago (1968-1970), changed him in stead. I do not believe a single person even of Obama’s ability and charisma can alter the system which allows the Congress to block the POTUS at every turn. I believe that Trump will suffer the same fate, despite the fact that the Republicans controlled both the House and the Senate. In the meantime, his tele-twitter diplomacy is upsetting everybody including the media. Will Secretary of State Rex be able to restrain him and stop Steve in The White House from making foreign policy decisions? Remember, Secretary William Rodgers could not separate Kissinger from Nixon. As a result, under Rodgers the State Department was sidelined. –Din Merican

  2. Most times, political / macroeconomic successes, failures or blunders are a matter of guided perceptions.

    Obama was never a showman, but his successor a consummate one.

    Though some early summary judgements could be proffered on Obama’s performance and legacy, it is too early on Trump’s.

    But my perception, right or wrong, is that Obama’s act is not too hard to follow, and as for Trump’s, I don’t see a greater showman than him coming along in 4 or 8 years time; hence Trump’s act, for better or worse, would be really hard to follow, assuming a shooting war did not break out between the US and China in which case history itself might have ended.

  3. The ACA (Affordable Care Act) was a major achievement of Obama, even if major concessions were granted to vested interests of the biomedical-industrial complex e.g. no public action to regulate drug prices.
    No American President since Johnson was able to pass major healthcare reform until Obama came along. Millions have been able to get health insurance coverage because of the ACA.

    It is actually illogical for the Trumpists to want to eliminate the ACA completely, with nothing new to take its place.

    • Phua:
      Given the millions of American now covered under ACA otherwise could not have healthcare insurance coverage, there is absolutely no way Trump could abolish ACA. I believe he will make some changes, give it a new name and call it his own, and thus fulfilled his campaign promise to rid of Obamacare.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.