President Barack Obama’s legacy: What happens now?

November 11, 2016

President Barack Obama’s legacy: What happens now?

By Sam Clench

The biggest loser of the US election wasn’t even on the ballot.

I’m not talking about Hillary Clinton, even though her political career has been crushed for good. No, the ultimate victim of Donald Trump’s stunning triumph is the man he will replace as president, Barack Obama.

“My name may not be on the ballot, but our progress is on the ballot,” Obama said before the election, urging his supporters to vote for Ms Clinton. “Tolerance is on the ballot. Democracy is on the ballot. Justice is on the ballot. Good schools are on the ballot. Hope is on the ballot.”

The president said he would consider it “a personal insult, an insult to my legacy” if Trump won. Well, here we are.

President-elect Donald Trump. Photo / AP
President-elect Donald Trump. Photo / AP

It’s a bizarre situation. Eight years ago, Obama was swept into power by America’s fury with his predecessor. This time, Trump won despite Obama’s remarkable popularity.

The president’s approval rating has risen steadily this year, and is now at its highest point since the heady days of his political honeymoon in late 2009.

“There’s a contrast with George W. Bush, who exited with very low favourability ratings,” Dr Gorana Grgic, a lecturer in US politics and foreign policy at the United States Studies Centre, tells “If you look at it from a historical perspective, Obama is up there.”

To give you some of that historical perspective, Obama’s ratings are comparable to those of Ronald Reagan, who often tops polls asking people to name the nation’s greatest president. But while Reagan’s legacy has shaped American politics for decades, Obama’s could vanish within months.

President Barack Obama on the campaign trail for Hillary Clinton. Photo / AP
President Barack Obama on the campaign trail for Hillary Clinton. Photo / AP

When Trump takes office, the Republican Party will control all three levers of power in Washington: the White House, Senate and House of Representatives. That means he will have free rein to pursue his agenda – and systematically dismantle Obama’s achievements.

The most obvious threat is to the president’s signature domestic policy, the health care law known as Obamacare. It’s already in trouble, with rising premiums and too few young, healthy people signing up to subsidise the nation’s older, sicker health insurance customers.

Obviously, Donald Trump has said that he would push for the repeal of Obamacare. The Republicans have already tried almost 50 times,” Dr Grgic says. Republican Senate leader Mitch McConnell has confirmed that repealing the law is a “pretty high item on our agenda”.

Dr Grgic argues the next president should focus on “getting more people into Obamacare, increasing competition and seeing whether something can be done about rising drug prices”. That is probably what Ms Clinton would have done.

Instead, Trump plans to scrap the whole thing and start again. Obama’s foreign policy record is flawed, but he has overseen a dramatic recovery in America’s reputation, which suffered badly during Bush’s second term.

“Obama has been pretty clear on what his outlook is for the way that the US engages with the world. It’s a very multilateral approach. and it’s principled on ‘don’t do stupid stuff’,” Dr Grgic says. “It was very much a reaction to what was perceived to be the overreach of the Bush administration.”

The world is somewhat less enthusiastic about a Trump presidency. A global poll taken shortly before the election showed people in every overseas country surveyed, with the exception of Russia, overwhelmingly preferred Ms Clinton.


Trump’s victory will clearly cause a seismic shift in America’s image – and its approach to the rest of the world.

The President-elect has been a scathing critic of Obama’s foreign policy doctrine. During the campaign, he called the much-hyped agreement with Iran, which aimed to curb the country’s efforts to develop nuclear weapons, “the worst deal ever negotiated”. Trump has promised to tear it up. He will also consider reversing Obama’s landmark decision to normalise relations with Cuba.

If those achievements are wiped away, Obama’s record will pretty much be reduced to the messes in Libya, Ukraine and Syria, which developed into a cataclysmic civil war on his watch.

“Obviously we have the nonintervention in Syria. Whether this was a mistake or not, we know Hillary Clinton was very vocal in support of a more assertive response,” Dr Grgic says.

“Obama had a very principled approach to foreign policy, and that involved mutual efforts and burden-sharing, and that simply wasn’t there in the early days of Syria.

“What you see in Syria now is a complete asymmetry of power, where you have the Assad regime being supported by Russia.”

President Barack Obama making Thanksgiving Day phone calls to U.S. troops, from the Oval Office in 2014. Photo / Pete Souza
President Barack Obama making Thanksgiving Day phone calls to U.S. troops, from the Oval Office in 2014. Photo / Pete Souza

Speaking of Russia, Obama’s efforts to rein in Vladimir Putin could be ditched completely when Trump takes control.

“There has been a complete breakdown basically of the relations between Russia and the US,” Dr Grgic says. That breakdown “started with the 2011 intervention in Libya,” which Putin opposed, and “spiralled” from there.

“It takes two to tango, right? I don’t think it’s just Obama’s fault for this one. It’s very clear that Putin has been very skilful in using this window of opportunity to assert Russia’s power,” she says. “When you are dealing with an autocratic leader, it’s very difficult to make a case for co-operation, when Putin is not constrained by the same factors as Obama.”

Trump repeatedly praised Putin during the campaign, calling him a “stronger leader” than Obama and suggesting he could work alongside the Russian dictator as an ally. That would mean a drastic reorientation of Obama’s foreign policy.


But put aside the policy implications of a future Trump administration for a moment, because part of the legacy Obama wanted to leave is in tatters already.

Back in 2008, Obama energised his voters with a promise to revolutionise politics in the United States. Sarah Palin infamously referred to this as the “hopey-changey stuff”, and perhaps she was right to mock it, because the bipartisan dream Obama spoke of so eloquently never materialised. That was partly his own fault.

“Obama is simply not the kind of politician that likes to get down and dirty with the kind of everyday politicking, and the horsetrading. He was simply not willing to engage in politics as it is usually done on Capitol Hill,” Dr Grgic says. That hindered the president’s ability to negotiate with Congress.

“A lot of people have said that it’s a kind of product of his personality and who he was previously. An academic, someone who’s very aloof maybe. He’d rather debate things, he’d rather try to show that his argument is plausible or he has more evidence to support his course of action than make those compromises.”

With the Republican Party pulled to the right by its base and Obama unable to break the gridlock in Washington, we’re now witnessing “the most polarising environment ever” in the US, she says.

That environment led directly to the rise of Donald Trump. It decimated the Democrats, whose numbers in Congress have plummeted, and who now face an utterly dominant Republican Party at both federal and state level.

Obama’s one great talent was getting himself elected. His party has crumbled around him over the last eight years, with most of its rising stars turfed from office, and now there is no obvious leader ready to pick up the pieces when he’s gone.

Obama isn’t the only one to blame for this – not even close – but it’s an undeniable fact that he failed to bring the country together. White people and minorities are bitterly divided. Urban elites and rural voters openly sneer at each other. And now, in a sickening dose of irony, America’s first black president will hand over the White House to the man who spent years hounding him with a racist birther conspiracy theory.

“We want to do everything we can to help you succeed. Because if you succeed, the country succeeds,” Obama told Trump when they met today. Those were the right words, and they sounded sincere.

But inside, even if he doesn’t show it, Obama must fear for his legacy. His proudest achievement, health care reform, is in mortal danger, his foreign policy doctrine is about to be reversed, and the nation he hoped to unite is seething with resentment.

Hillary Clinton lost an election, and I’m sure it hurts badly. But Barack Obama could lose everything his presidency stood for, and that is far worse.



9 thoughts on “President Barack Obama’s legacy: What happens now?

  1. If I were an African American I would have tried my utmost to be there in person to hear Obama’s first Presidential address… and I would have been proud that here was one of my kind standing there as the most powerful person in the world and delivering such a message… of change.

    What eloquence…and what a stunning delivery…above all, my President was going to change our country…I would have shed tears of joy…

    What a Presidency, though…change he certainly has brought…but change for the worse…our country continues to murder innocent foreigners who have never posed any threat to the US…millions of my countrymen have no hope for a future for themselves or for their children…and, above all, my President can assassinate anyone he so wishes without any recourse to due process…but above all, my country now has had Habeus Corpus trampled upon… the single most important guarantee that a citizen can get his voice heard… Yes, how my President has brought about change…

    So now as I witness his term come to an end, I once again shed tears…but this time of shame…shame that one of my kind has let our country down in such fashion…

    Shame on you Barack Hussain Obama…shame on you…

  2. Isa,
    As if you the melayu majority treats us the minorities. Be honest! Stop bullshitting. This election result is the revolt of angry white men. This is the template that will be used by Najib to rule Malaysia forever. When it comes to that, it’s time to look at partition as viable solution.
    Especially after all these years being true blue Malaysian and yet treated 2nd class citizen in own country

  3. Well Mr Isa M,

    Obama could have been a second FDR but he did not rise to the occasion.

    Still, he has been a better President than George W.

  4. Any presidential contender who cannot win the majority of white votes cannot be representative of America. So Obama does not represent America. He failed on this account during both occassions that he was elected and re-elected (I stand to be corrected on this). Perhaps this may remain a record in American history for another 200 years.

    He has the gift of the gab and an arrogant stance in mocking others. He is an over rated under achiever.

  5. Any presidential contender who cannot win the majority of white votes cannot be representative of America. So Obama does not represent America. He failed on this account during both occassions that he was elected and re-elected (I stand to be corrected on this). Perhaps this may remain a record in American history for another 200 years.

    He has the gift of the gab and an arrogant stance in mocking others. He is an over estimated under achiever – all fluff and no stuff.

  6. Obama couldn’t do much as Congress was controlled by the Republicans and they have sworn to oppose anything that Obama put forth. The appointment of a Supreme Court Justice is one example and Obamacare is another. Congress even overruled Obama’s veto, so how can a President do his job when he is opposed by Congress on every move he makes.

    To many who are not conversant with the powers and authority of POTUS, the President powers are limited. Congress has the final say unlike in Malaysia where the PM can bill dozed every bill and legislation through Parliament.

  7. Yes, a President’s powers are limited …in theory… but so how does the Executive Order mechanism work? Somebody please advise…

  8. Isa Manteqi, you might want to refer to Article II of the US Constitution that explains the powers of the POTUS and how he needs the advise and consent of Congress on issues before him.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.