The Long Shadow of J. Edgar Hoover

November 1, 2016

by Tim Weiner

Do the words “extremely careless” ring a bell?

The Federal Bureau of Investigation’s director, James B. Comey, threw that stinging criticism at Hillary Clinton in July, shortly after announcing that the bureau’s long investigation of her handling of classified information had turned up no crime. Now he faces the same judgment from her — and his superiors at the Justice Department.

In hurling barbs at Mrs. Clinton, Mr. Comey has at once revived his reputation for confronting commanders in chief and resurrected the spirit of the F.B.I.’s most infamous high priest. Somewhere, tearing wings off flies in a dark star chamber in the sky, J. Edgar Hoover is smiling. The use of secret information to wound public figures was one of his favorite sports.

The United States has spent many years trying to stand clear of Hoover’s long shadow. But it lengthens in an age of relentless government surveillance and pitiless political publicity. And Mr. Comey has chosen to become a singular force in American politics. His miscalculated decision to unleash his letter to Clinton hunters in Congress looked less like a legal maneuver than an act of political warfare.

The F.B.I. has an essential role in national security and law enforcement, and it also has the awesome power to destroy someone, delivering blows as only the bureau can. It cannot and must not devolve into what it was in the 20th century after the Cold War — a backbiting, bitter, badly led phalanx of spies with guns — or revert to its old role under Hoover as an instrument of political warfare.

Thomas Kean, the Republican chairman of the September 11 commission, concluded more than a decade ago: “We can’t continue in this country with an intelligence agency with the record the F.B.I. has. You have a record of an agency that’s failed, and it’s failed again and again and again.” That is one reason President Obama chose Mr. Comey in 2013: to command and control the F.B.I. under the rule of law.

Yet despite that mandate, the bureau remains the closest thing we have in this country to a secret police. With the barest oversight from lawmakers, Mr. Comey sits at F.B.I. headquarters — the J. Edgar Hoover Building, that crumbling Brutalist parking garage deliberately situated midway between the White House and Congress — playing by his own rules.

Only Mr. Comey can tell us why he went public with a weeks-old investigation into the emails of the Clinton aide Huma Abedin and her estranged husband, a certain ex-congressman (for the record, Anthony Weiner is no relation). But it was immediately clear that Mr. Comey had violated Justice Department protocols in disclosing the case at its earliest stages.

The only explanation I can think of is a barely plausible one, which delves into the terrain of the cheap political thriller, but hews to the twisted plots of this presidential campaign. F.B.I. agents in Washington and New York were frustrated after laboring mightily on the former secretary of state’s handling of classified emails and producing no indictable offense. Mr. Comey, who must flourish or fail by the respect in which his agents hold him, revived the thrill of their chase when a federal case against the aforementioned ex-congressman developed, and now the F.B.I. was on the hunt again. Its agents seized a computer from him; emails from Ms. Abedin were on it.

Were these communiqués classified? Threats to national security? Recipes for risotto or blueprints for building a hydrogen bomb? And what if anything did they reveal about the epistolary endeavors of the former secretary of state and current Democratic nominee for president? The F.B.I. had no idea when Mr. Comey made his remarkable disclosure.

This case is not about personalities. Mr. Comey is not Hoover’s ghost. Nor should it be about politics. The F.B.I. is supposed to be above that. But it is about power, its use and abuse.

Mr. Comey’s reputation for independence in the face of executive power was forged in a 2004 confrontation with President George W. Bush over the widespread and mostly secret warrant less searches of Americans’ emails. When Mr. Comey, then the acting attorney general, found out about it he confronted the president, declared the program illegal, and said he would resign if it were not altered or abolished. He later reflected that it was hard to straddle the tracks in front of a speeding railroad train and yell, Stop!”

Sadly for many who admired his courage, Mr. Comey now more closely resembles the runaway train. His conduct calls to mind the testimony of another Secretary of State, George P. Shultz, in the aftermath of the Iran-contra imbroglio — the disastrous decision by the Reagan administration to sell overpriced weapons to Iran’s Revolutionary Guards, skim off the proceeds, and slip millions to rebel cadres in Central America after Congress had cut off its support.

Mr. Shultz said, of the Director of Central Intelligence during the Iran-contra affair, William J. Casey: “The C.I.A. and Bill Casey were as independent as a hog on ice and could be as confident as they were wrong.” Substitute “the F.B.I. and Jim Comey” and we have a sense of where we are.

In his role as the Director of the Bureau, Mr. Comey is not supposed to be a Republican or a Democrat. He is supposed to stand as the living embodiment of the statue of Justice — wearing a blindfold, holding a sword in one hand, a balancing scale in the other. In light of his recent conduct, the blindfold and the sword seem intact, but the scale seems to have gone missing. America could use the balance.


10 thoughts on “The Long Shadow of J. Edgar Hoover

  1. I have not witnessed since 1968, a nastier, dirtier and more divisive American Presidential election campaign. It shows that American democracy can be dysfunctional and faulty. I blame the mainstream media for this. I hope America can recover from this shameful display of gutter politics by the democrats and the republicans. President Obama should not take the side of Hillary Clinton since he is on the way out. Instead he should ensure that America is safe during this transition. –Din Merican

  2. In a way it is also 21st century American democratic politics at its best. If you have the ambition to be the most powerful man or woman in the World in this Internet Age then you had better show you have what it takes to survive your term at the Oval Office.

    In this election at least, whoever wins wins it on the acceptance, grudgingly or not, of the American voters of all your faults and failings. You have not much to worry about once you take office.

  3. I remember Tom Hayden laughed about his F.B.I. files piled up to five feet tall, calling those agents “F**king Big Idiots.”

  4. I remember Tom Hayden laughed about his F.B.I. files piled up to five feet tall, calling those agents “F**king Big Idiots.”

    Most Americans believe secret police only exist in countries like Russia and China but not in the U.S. My friend Leland Yee, the California State Senator, was entrapped by the F.B.I. and is now in jail. The funny thing is that they linked his case to that of Raymond “Shrimp Boy” Chow, the Dragon Head of the Hung Brotherhood. I know both of them and know they do not see things eye to eye, in fact, they hate each other. I was in a meeting with them over the building of a new campus for San Francisco City College in Chinatown. Boy, how they hated each other. But the F.B.I. said they collaborated to commit crime together.

  5. Of course, as far as Tim Weiner and NYT are concerned, Killary’s shit doesn’t stink. However, there are always two sides to a story. It seems like James B. Comeyis caught between a rock and a hard place.

  6. Din,
    How to ensure Malaysia is safe during transition when there is a possibility that Trump will be the next President. Oh come on! Lee Kuan Yew is right about people like Trump. He will ensure that Trump type shall be locked up behind bars with keys thrown away

  7. Every nation has its way of digging out truth. In the United States of Americans, competing voice is the way for figuring what is truth and what is false. Here is front page investigative report by Wall Street Journal on how Justice Department and FBI fight over how to proceed with investigation on Clinton Foundation:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.