Razali Ismail and his Merry Men at Suhakam

August 3, 2015

Razali Ismail and his Merry Men at Suhakam: Get  the Job Done

by Azmi Sharom


Much is expected of the current Suhakam commissioners. Will they be bold defenders of human rights in Malaysia?

WHEN the new list of commissioners for the Human Rights Com­mission of Malaysia (Suhakam) was announced, I was quietly optimistic. In the line-up are a few individuals who have a good record in defending human rights and this is a good thing.

With its funding slashed, Suhakam now depends on the vitality of its commissioners more than ever.

The new chairman, Tan Sri Razali Ismail, a former diplomat (and first Malaysian to  be President of the United Nations General Assembly), was a fairly inoffensive choice. Diplomats being diplomats, they are really hard to pin down, smoothly shifting gears to whatever is required in the name of diplomacy. They tend to do that even when no longer in the diplomatic corps. I suppose decades as a professional smooth talker can have that effect.

Tan Sri Hasmy Agam –Effective Head of Suhakam

Hasmy Agam–Got the Job done, Thanks

That being said, the last head of Suhakam, Tan Sri Hasmy Agam, was also a diplomat and although he had started his job rather timidly, in my opinion he grew into the role, absorbing the values and then defending human rights to a level that I had not expected.

Now it would appear that the new head has a lot of growing into the role to do, too. The chairperson’s seat is not even warm yet and already Razali has displayed a lack of understanding, not only of what human rights entail, but also the situation in the country.

His statement in last week’s Sunday Star that Bersih 2.0 has to find “more sophisticated” methods to make their point rather than organising street protests, was disappointing to say the least. He says such protests “damage a lot of property and all that”.

Granted that he conceded to the point that to demonstrate is a human right, but this is tempered by him saying that the authorities have to “weigh all the parties’ interests”.

I take issue with his points. First, what on earth does he mean by “more sophisticated methods”? Shall we write memorandum after memorandum and hand them to the Government, hoping and praying that it will read the memoranda and take them seriously?

What about politely worded e-mails to our MPs, asking them to do something in Parliament?I suppose we can wait for the next general election or write passionate letters to the editor. When has any of these things worked?

Even a petition with a million signatories can be denigrated and brushed aside. So, just what other avenues do we the people have?

Will smooth talking Razali stand up to this Human Rights Abuser?

You see, Razali may have lots of charm (as he implies in the interview) with which to cajole recalcitrant government types, but those of us without bespoke suits and the standing of the new Suhakam chair will probably find it difficult to get anywhere close to those who stalk the corridors of power.And has Razali ever been to any of these so-called destructive protests?

There has been damage in the past, true, but the level of damage is miniscule compared to the number of participants.If tens of thousands of people want to cause damage, then by golly, you’ll see real damage.

But this is not the case and in the last Bersih rally, which lasted one and a half days and not three as Razali said,  there were teams of volunteers picking up the trash left behind.

Oh, and may I just point out that what the Government deems as “in the best interest” can be warped at times. For example, the (not so smart) Inspector-General of Police said Bersih could organise a protest as long as it didn’t call for the leaders to step down.

How many times must it be said? The top government leaders can be dismissed from their jobs.It needs a vote of no confidence in a legislative body.

There is nothing unconstitutional or undemocratic about a head of government being forced to step down. So if people want this, as long as they are not suggesting the removal be done in any way unlawful, like a military coup or elimination by a game show, then it is perfectly within their rights to do so.

You see, saudara Razali, the government agencies and their heads who determine “best interest” really are not able to do so. Instead of giving the excuses that have been used to shut down dissent, the head of Suhakam has to defend our human and constitutional rights to the nth degree. And Lord knows we need them now.

We are fed up with financial misdeeds and mismanagement, and if we want to show our frustration, the only real avenue is to gather peacefully and in huge numbers.

It doesn’t matter if Suhakam will continue to charmingly try to convince the Malaysian Govern­ment to sign more international treaties.All that comes to nought if the commission can’t even be bold enough to stand up for the rights of the people of Malaysia now.

Azmi Sharom (azmi.sharom@gmail.com) is a law teacher. The views expressed here are entirely the writer’s own.

7 thoughts on “Razali Ismail and his Merry Men at Suhakam

  1. Just look at what LGE has done to himself. Surely there are better ways to conduct yourself and avoid legal issues.

  2. Razali is as smooth as silk. But I am not sure he is really suited for the job which requires the leadership of someone who is truly committed to human rights and can speak the truth to power. His comments on BERSIH 2.0 are not doing him any good. He is already being perceived as a Najib man. Anyway as a friend and fellow Kedahan, I wish him well. –Din Merican

  3. Quote:- “…be bold enough to stand up for the rights of the people of Malaysia now”

    If that is a probable outcome coming from Razali Ismail’s appointment, he won’t be appointed to the post in the first place. Najib is not that stupid. He doesn’t want another mosquito buzzing around his ear.

    So we can write Razali off straight away.

  4. Our politicians and top civil servants are like old plastic bottles. They don’t retire but are recycled over and over again and like the recycled bottles, their quality gets worse with each cycle.

  5. As an individual we are repeatedly told by our parents, teachers and government not to repeat our mistakes. Once you are an adult it the duty and responsibility of the law to tell us not to repeat our mistakes. Over to you Mr. Law.

  6. i also used to think razali has brain since uni days. his statement on bersih indicate his south bound drop in integrity is very sad.
    Yes, tpcheam, you and I who know him well are disappointed. –Din Merican

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s