Respect Citizens’ Right to Participation in Governance Mr Apandi Ali told

February 7, 2016

Malaysia’s  Attorney-General Apandi Ali told: Respect Citizens’ Right to Participation in Governance

by Edgardo Legaspi

COMMENT | It was a rather unfortunate statement from Attorney-General Mohamed Apandi Ali (on harsher punishments for press who report on information leaks), one which may move Malaysia further backwards in its path toward transparency, accountability and democracy.

His reference to China is telling – as this is one of the most restrictive countries in the world – and it may indicate the direction he wants to the country to go. Malaysia has two states with Freedom of Information (FOI) laws (Selangor and Penang). This is a rarity in the region (only Indonesia and Thailand have FOI laws).

Now Apandi is threatening to strengthen the Official Secrets Act (OSA) by imposing harsher penalties on violators – and including medieval corporal punishment at that.

The A-G need not be too literal when looking at the constitution. It is true that the ‘right to know’ is not explicitly written in it, but it is generally accepted that freedom of information is an essential component to the practice of freedom of expression, as a guarantee to ensure public participation in governance.

This view is too literal. Is he also going to argue that Malaysia need not guarantee press freedom because it is not written in the constitution?He may well also argue that since Malaysia has not ratified the international covenant on civil and political rights, which is more explicit on FOI (“right to seek, receive… information”), that the country is not obliged to guarantee this right.

Secrecy means something to hide

As chief lawyer of the state, such a statement is irresponsible, as his duty is to promote the rule of law and public interest. It is not his job to defend politicians and government officials. On the contrary, his role is to protect the country and its people from abuse committed by such people.

The problem is that official secrecy is often used to hide corruption and state abuses.In these instances, whistleblowers must be protected as these disclosures are in the interest of the public and the country.

Who will be the Next Governor of Bank Negara and  who is the Replacement for MACC Top Post will confirm that 1mDB Cover-up is complete

Apandi’s statements are also a serious threat to freedom of the press.By threatening to prosecute journalists who disseminate information from whistleblowers, he is in effect telling the media to avoid covering such stories, or else face the risk of a criminal case.

The obligation of the media is to the public – to facilitate free speech and public participation by keeping citizens informed, especially about public affairs. To raise this threat of prosecution by forcing journalists to reveal their sources is a direct attack on the public trust that the media is trying to build.

Protection of journalistic sources is sacred in keeping this trust.It is precisely because whistleblowers face the threats and the risk of attacks from powerful people that protection of sources is at the core of journalistic ethics.

Related stories:

We’re truth seekers, not saboteurs, journalists tell AG

Rafizi: AG has no credibility to propose OSA amendments

Punishing the messenger, sparing the wrongdoer

EDGARDO LEGASPI is Southeast Asian Press Alliance (SEAPA) Executive Director.


6 thoughts on “Respect Citizens’ Right to Participation in Governance Mr Apandi Ali told

  1. He is going to do it. Critics are way behind the curve. The man is PUBLIC MENACE – a true blue ZEALOT all self- wraped in Islam.

  2. When you guys ever learn that under the present system, you will never get justice. Stop being delusional la. Why would these elites wanna change when the present system would preserve their rule forever and ever?

    Either take it to a next level or quit the country

  3. Would-be leakers should leak what they got to the foreign media which can then be safely quoted by the local media. Foreign media will protect their sources – no worry. Remember this is Internet Era – no idiots from the officialdom can restrict information from the public. Let those idiots fabricate any damned rules & regulations as they like, they will be beaten.

  4. The guy is put in that post by cheappi to cleanse him of all the dirt on his “emperor cloth”. Apparently he is seen to be doing his job with extreme zeal and gusto, not unlike the eunuchs portrayed in some of those sword-fighting kung-fu movies that was once popular. It should not be surprising that he is doing what cheappi expecteing of what he should be doing.

  5. The guy is put in his place by cheappi. He owes it to him and his main task is to cleanse cheappi of all his dirt on his “emperor cloth”. So expect more of his antics of “protecting” security of the nation.

  6. There is the story in the 60s of this Marketing Director who brought in the best sales for his cigarette company for ten years in a row. But he could not get his son to cut his hair.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.