A Damning Report on Malaysia’s New Autocrat by The Washington Post

November 30, 2015

Obama shakes hands with Najib

The New Autocrat shakes hands with The Democrat

A Damning Report on Malaysia’s New Autocrat by The Washington Post

by Anna Fifield


Online critics of the Malaysian government would be well advised not to spend too much money on cellphones. “Just lost number four,” Eric Paulsen, an outspoken civil liberties lawyer and compulsive tweeter, said Nov. 20 after nearly two hours of questioning at the main police station here over his latest sedition charge.

Paulsen went into the Police station with a shiny new Chinese handset, a Xiaomi, and came out without it. At least it was cheaper than the iPhone and two Samsung Galaxies that previously were confiscated from him this year, apparently because they are tools in his social-media activism.


MP Steven Sim Tze Tzin

His friend Steven Sim Tze Tzin, an opposition parliamentarian who also was questioned that day, still smarts over the iPhone 6 Plus that was taken from him this year. “Don’t they know how much that thing cost?” Sim said, laughing, after emerging from his own session with the Police.

Malaysia, ostensibly one of the United States’ democratic allies in Southeast Asia, is engaged in a broad crackdown on freedom of expression that detractors say is all about silencing critics of Prime Minister Najib Razak, who is embroiled in a corruption scandal. And the crackdown is particularly focused on online commentary, which is proving much harder to control than traditional media.

“The government has at least two intentions,” said Yin Shao Loong, who is Executive Director of the Institut Rakyat, a think tank, and is aligned with the opposition. “One is to stifle freedom of expression. The other is to harass the opposition and sap their energy and tie them up in court cases that could take years.”

Najib’s government has been making heavy use of the 1948 Sedition Act, a remnant of the British colonial period, which makes it an offense to “bring into hatred or contempt or to excite disaffection against any Ruler or against any Government.”

Azmi Sharom 3

University of Malaya’s Dr. Azmi Sharom

Among the three dozen or so who have been targeted so far this year are  Dr.Azmi Sharom, a law professor at the University of Malaya who gave his legal opinion on a 2009 political crisis, and Maria Chin Abdullah, the leader of the Bersih group, a civil-society organization that promotes electoral reform, who has been charged with illegal assembly and sedition for organizing huge anti-Najib rallies in August.

Numerous opposition parliamentarians also have been charged with sedition, most of them for criticizing a federal court’s decision in February upholding the conviction of opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim on charges of sodomy. That case is widely viewed as political.

S. Arutchelvan, a socialist politician, was charged in the past week with sedition for comments he made in February. The well-known cartoonist Zunar, who in September won an International Press Freedom Award from the Committee to Protect Journalists, has been charged with nine counts of sedition for nine tweets criticizing the Anwar conviction.

Congrats Zunar

Award Winning Malaysian Cartoonist ZUNAR

And two newspapers deemed hostile to the government were suspended from publishing.“Prime Minister Najib Razak and the Malaysian government are making a mockery of their claim to be a rights-respecting democracy by prosecuting those who speak out on corruption or say anything even remotely critical of the government,” said Linda Lakhdhir of Human Rights Watch. The government, she added, should stop using “repressive laws to harass the media and intimidate its critics.”

The crackdown began after the ruling party fared poorly in 2013 elections, said Murray Hiebert, an expert on Southeast Asia at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, but the repression has accelerated amid a corruption scandal that threatens Najib’s hold on power.

Investigators looking into the heavily indebted sovereign wealth fund, 1Malaysia Development Berhad, or 1MDB, found that almost $700 million (Malaysian ringgit 2.6 billion) had been deposited into Najib’s personal bank accounts, the Wall Street Journal has reported.

Najib, who founded 1MDB and heads its board of advisers, has strenuously denied any wrongdoing. Arif Shah, a spokesman for 1MDB, said the allegations against Najib were “old” and had been “comprehensively addressed” by the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission, which in August reported that no funds from 1MDB had been transferred to the Prime Minister’s personal bank accounts.

But amid investigations into the fund, Najib has replaced key officials with appointees deemed friendlier. The new Attorney-General, for example, has dismissed a recommendation from the central bank to begin criminal proceedings against 1MDB.

For Peace and Freedom

The Prime Minister’s Office did not respond directly to questions about Najib’s links to the fund, saying the investigation continues, but a spokesman strongly denied suggestions that opponents of the government were being targeted with legal action.

“The Sedition Act does not impinge on free speech or democratic principles,” said Dato’ Tengku Sariffuddin, the ‘Prime Minister’s press secretary. “Most, if not all, countries have legal safeguards on the printed and spoken word in order to maintain public order. It is reasonable for Malaysia to safeguard itself in the same manner.”

Pending amendments to the Sedition Act, he said, would serve “to better protect all religions and to prevent the incitement of racial or inter-ethnic conflict.”

The changes would remove a clause outlawing criticism of the government and judiciary. A provision would be added to outlaw incitement to religious hatred in the country, which is 60 percent Muslim. The amendments, once ratified, also would increase the term of imprisonment for sedition from three years to seven years and add a penalty of up to 20 years in prison for seditious activities that result in physical harm or destruction of property.

The spokesman said that Malaysia has “a thriving online space in which opposition voices and publications are given free rein” and that government critics “are more outspoken than in almost any other country in the region.” But critics of Najib describe an elaborate effort to silence them. The Malaysian government has long controlled newspapers and TV stations. Although the rising use of cellphones and social media has loosened the state’s grip on information, especially in rural regions, the government is trying to get a handle on the new technologies.

“There are lots of cybertroopers monitoring posts by opposition [members of Parliament], taking screen shots of them and then circulating them and tagging the Police Chief,” said the opposition parliamentarian Steven Sim, who is being charged for a tweet in which he mistakenly suggested that the former attorney general was manhandled out of office. Sim deleted the tweet when he realized that the photo included was an old one and said it was a genuine mistake. Too late.

“The cybertroopers wrote, ‘Arrest Sim. He’s giving the government a bad name,’ ” the legislator said. It is not clear whether these online monitors are hired by the government or are zealous volunteers. But they have been effective at alerting the authorities to criticism.

For Paulsen, 42, an ethnic Chinese lawyer who leads a human rights advocacy group called Lawyers for Liberty, problems began after the terrorist attack on the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo in Paris in January.

A government official said such an attack could happen here, prompting Paulsen to send out a tweet about the Department of Islamic Advancement Malaysia, or JAKIM, which prescribes the sermons delivered during politically slanted Friday prayers.

“JAKIM is promoting extremism every Friday. Goverment needs to address that if serious about extremism in Malaysia,” Paulsen tweeted. The cybertroopers seized on it. The next day, Khalid Abu Bakar, the fawning Inspector General of Police, who also is active on Twitter, posted a photo of Paulsen and his tweet overlaid with the word “rude.”

Then came Paulsen’s first sedition charge. The second was filed after he tweeted that the most extreme forms of Islamic punishment, such as cutting off hands and stonings, were inhumane. The third run-in with the law was a criminal defamation charge after two tweets suggesting that Najib was trying to avoid questioning over the 1MDB affair.

Paulsen does not deny writing any of the tweets, but he does assert his innocence on the fourth allegation against him, which concerns a Facebook post showing a banner in a march that had been doctored to read, “Chinese pigs go home.”

“It was clearly fabricated to make it look like I had posted this,” he said, adding that it seemed designed to provoke racial divisions.

Paulsen said he thinks the efforts against him are part of a broader attempt to silence criticism of the government on social media. “If you’re from the opposition, are a dissident or are active in civil society, they’re going to come after you.”

But Lakhdhir of Human Rights Watch finds some cause for optimism. “A bright light for Malaysia is the strength of its civil society,” she said, “with many who are willing to speak out despite the risks.”

Anna Fifield is The Post’s bureau chief in Tokyo, focusing on Japan and the Koreas. She previously reported for the Financial Times from Washington DC, Seoul, Sydney, London and from across the Middle East.

13 thoughts on “A Damning Report on Malaysia’s New Autocrat by The Washington Post

  1. A few years back, it was unusual for the US press to write anything about Malaysia. But now things are different. This Washington Post article is one more example that the major US newspapers are now all very aware of Najib’s crackdown on political freedom and the corruption scandals that surround him. I doubt that there is anyone in power in the US or the outside world who would praise Najib as the “great reformer” now.
    Thanks Ambassador Malott,

    Najib should learn that you can lie to some people all time, especially if you have money to give, but never all people in Malaysia and around the world all the time. But being an aristocratic moron born with a silver spoon in his mouth, he is prone to flattery from bigger morons under him. I am afraid, we have to live with him and his avaricious wife, Rosmah Mansor, for some time to come.

    Frankly, I would not mind having Zahid Hamidi as Prime Minister with Khairy Jamaluddin as his Deputy.We must also get rid of Hishamuddin and in so doing, we will eliminate the perception that only sons of former PMs can be prime minister. Like the tradition in American political culture, every one can be President.That is the American Dream.–Din Merican

  2. The police should have a huge collection of handphones and computers confiscated from the media, bloggers, opposition members and activists. They also confiscate handphones if they is found to contain 4-D numbers.
    They charge you for being an illegal 4D agent or punter.
    I wonder what happens to all these phones and computers. They must cost quite a sum.

  3. Strange to see MP Sim speaking in front of redshirt poster. That shows Keadilan’s willingness to speak across the aisle😘. Time for KJ to speak in front of yellow shirts😝 We love KJ better than PM Najib. Watch out, our beloved 1PM. Show your blue blood quick.. else these peasants will take over your inheritance.

  4. One final post – Johnny Clegg (white South African anthropologist, musician, social activist, proponent of Rainbow Nation multiculturalism) :

  5. Face the fact, the damage of 1MDB, MYR2.6 billion “donation” is DONE. its really mostly over. Pursuing these issues is about accountability – making those who caused it to rightfully pay – and the use of force, the sledgehammer being used is about not wanting to pay..Frankly speaking Malaysia has a very long track record of poor accountability and paying for these things – thanks to Mahathir..

    So really what really is there to do for??? Truth is punishing Najib (+1?) and all sundry and others is NOT what we do, its just not us to have that kind of determination – its Mahathir but not us.

    What is to do really is Najib has proven himself unqualifed for the next future. That really is what is left to do..He clearly is not responsible for “transformation” and growth in the last few years and will not deliver for the coming future of slow growth – he will blame “extrenal circumstances” etc – he is a man of excuses..What we need is truly transformative in time of less certainty – that is not Najib, its not Muhiyiddin, its not anyone from UMNO. Tawfik Ismail is right, its better to hand the country over to the likes of Rafizi Ramli, Nik Nazmi and even KJ than it is the existing regime.

  6. It’s getting very boring talking and reading about Najib with nearly everyone, Malaysians & foreigners alike with the exceptions of his loyal supporters, appearing to agree that he is not fit to continue as the PM of Malaysia or even perhaps the President of UMNO. Nothing short of an election will ever remove him from either position. The GE14 will decide his position as the PM but with reference to his position in his party, the party election has already been postponed to a much later date. Malaysians can only pin their hopes for change through the GE14 – if the vast majority of voters go against UMNO/BN like a big never-seen-before tsunami, no amount of fiddling will be able to change the true results of GE14. Just be patient, and wait for that – and don’t complain if UMNO/BN were elected again……that would mean the majority of voters actually love Najib as their PM.

  7. I prefer donkeys replacing Najib, Zahid and the entire cabinet. At least the donkeys just bray and don’t spew rubbish when they open their mouths. On top of that, the donkeys have more intelligence than Najib and his cabinet.

  8. A Damning Report on Malaysia’s New Autocrat by The Washington Post

    Does anyone in power care what the TWP thinks?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.