Criminalizing Malaysia’s Opposition


May 13, 2015

Phnom Penh by The Mekong

The Opinion Pages | Op-Ed Contributor

Criminalizing Malaysia’s Opposition

by Nurul izzah Anwar, Member of Parliament

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/13/opinion/criminalizing-malaysias-opposition.html?ref=world&_r=1

World leaders need to tell Mr. Najib and his cronies that trade and economic considerations, including the much talked about Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement, will not be placed above civil and political rights. It’s time for Malaysia’s friends around the world to stop giving our leaders a pass on sharply declining human rights and the rule of law.–Nurul izzah Anwar

Nurul IzzahKUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia — Last Thursday, my mother was elected the new member of Malaysia’s Parliament from Permatang Pauh, a seat that was wrested away from the opposition through the politically motivated conviction of my father, Anwar Ibrahim, a former Deputy Prime Minister and the country’s Opposition Leader. In February, the highest court in Malaysia sent him to prison for five years on trumped up charges of sodomy. He is serving his third prison sentence since 1999.

In March, I delivered a speech in Parliament focused on good governance and judicial reform on behalf of my father. The reading was deemed seditious by the government, and I was arrested and locked up overnight.

The Sedition Act, which criminalizes speech uttered “to excite disaffection” against the government, is one of this administration’s favorite cudgels. Its definition is so broad that it gives the government sweeping powers to arrest and lock up critics under the guise of punishing “sedition” or in the ostensible pursuit of maintaining public order.

In the last two years, it has been used successfully to harass or prosecute scores of people, mostly government officials, including several members of Parliament. The cartoonist Zulkiflee Anwar Ulhaque, better known as Zunar, was hit with nine charges under the Sedition Act — mostly based on tweets allegedly attacking the Judiciary over the verdict against my father. His artwork and cartoons were confiscated, and he is now out on bail.

In addition to harassing me and persecuting my father, the state has applied constant pressure on my mother, a state assemblywoman, in hopes that she will wilt both physically and psychologically. The Police have also hinted of their plans to interrogate my younger sister, Nurul Nuha, who is leading March 2 Freedom, a coalition to free my father.

We are running out of family members for officials to arrest on bogus charges. What’s most alarming is that the government’s actions are part of a much larger pattern of threats to the rule of law and human rights. In recent months, every week or so brings news of the politically motivated detention of a government critic. I am out on bail now, but my arrest is intended to silence me and to warn other would-be government critics.

The United Malays National Organization, known as UMNO, and its allies have been in power since independence in 1957. The tempo of state repression quickened two years ago after the 2013 parliamentary elections when the opposition won 51 percent of votes cast, versus 47 percent for the government.

Through gerrymandering and the creation of uneven electoral districts, the ruling coalition clung to power by holding on to 60 percent of the seats. The Electoral Integrity Project, an international organization, recently rated Malaysia as having the worst electoral-district boundaries in the world and among the worst election rules. This places Malaysia alongside countries like Zimbabwe, Angola and Egypt.

The opposition’s showing at the polls two years ago was a political near-death experience for Prime Minister Najib Razak and the ruling party. It was answered with investigations, arrests and imprisonment.

Meanwhile, UMNO, whose main constituency has historically been the ethnic Malay Muslim majority, with help from its pliant coalition partners, has cynically raised the mercury on issues related to race, religion and the Malaysian royal family, so as to keep the mult-ethnic opposition coalition on the defensive.

Religious freedom in a country with sizable Christian, Buddhist and Hindu minorities is now endangered as public figures vying for popular support among Muslims have supported the persecution of religious minorities. Christians, who make up about 10 percent of the population, have been a prime target.

Last month, for example, in one high-profile incident, demonstrators in Petaling Jaya demanded that Christians remove a cross from the exterior of their church — and the cross was removed. And in 2013, Ibrahim Ali, a leader of Perkasa, a Malay supremacist organization, allegedly publicly endorsed the burning of Bibles.

Instead of focusing on dissenters, government officials should be doing their jobs. For one thing, Malaysia’s economy needs revamping. A sizable portion of the working population in a young country of 30 million citizens still remains eligible for welfare cash handouts. We are too reliant on natural resources. The gap between the rich and poor has been growing and is now among the widest in the region. Our education system remains weak and incoherently structured, creating an unemployable class with poor career prospects.

The Pakatan Rakyat opposition coalition that my party is a part of aims to focus on structural reforms in key economic policies with the goal of creating a clean and more effective government. Reducing inequality and the cost of living, providing affordable housing, good governance and a serious fight against corruption are our priorities.

Malaysia’s answer to extremism has been economic opportunity. Now that this deal is faltering, and now that the borders are porous — more than 1,000 refugees from Myanmar and Bangladesh landed on our shores on Monday — there is a risk that extremism could find a home here.

It’s encouraging that Mahathir Mohamad, the country’s former long-time Prime Minister, has recently become Prime Minister Najib’s fiercest critic, attacking him as corrupt and incompetent.

But we need louder voices to condemn what’s happening here. World leaders need to tell Mr. Najib and his cronies that trade and economic considerations, including the much talked about Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement, will not be placed above civil and political rights. It’s time for Malaysia’s friends around the world to stop giving our leaders a pass on sharply declining human rights and the rule of law.

3 thoughts on “Criminalizing Malaysia’s Opposition

  1. Miss Nurul Izzah Anwar,

    I think many hear your call. But I opine that world leaders cannot do much about internal politics of Malaysia until, possibly, we had much direr situation such as coup, civil strife, beheading and the likes. Seeing from outside Malaysia, Malaysia is in Muslim-majority nations club and has been given handicap-point as in golf games (club membership comes with privilege). That is why Obama visited Malaysia hailing Malaysia as the best model of the nations of its category.

    To get out of the handicap-point club, we are on our own. I think your article in New York Times would be better served if you concluded at the end by showing the opposition’s determination to take up the responsibility on their own. That would have earned more respect in the land of the free and home of the brave. Aid and help are for nations such as Yemen. Moral support is an illusion created by the American left works at best only inconsistently. Lee Kuan Yew’s pragmatic and shred approach worked better including whipping Michael Fay when you know American conservative was silently backing your decision despite overt moral indignation from American lefts including the then President Clinton. In short, our country is our responsibility.
    _____________________
    I agree,

    The motivation for writing this article is to free her father from prison and she thinks the Obama administration can apply pressure on Najib. Wrong. The US President is more interested in getting Malaysia to sign the TPPA. That is in America’s interest. Europe is too preoccupied with internal problems to care. Forget about Russia and China. I also think that our opposition has no real leader to lead the country as they are in disarray. Hadi wants to be PM and that would be a disaster. For the opposition their high point was the 2008 elections. Anwar spoilt it by his September 16 move that probably triggered Sodomy 2. –Din Merican

  2. The poor girl is wasting her time with the Yanks. The Blacks similarly thought Obama would do them a treat. Sad to say nothing radical has happened, Blacks getting shot by the police. With such mountains Obama has to climb, can he do any better with the Anwar saga? Black or white yellow or green politics is a dirty game, rather politics made a dirty game by dirty people.

  3. Why yes, the American left is to blame for everything wrong with the World. Perhaps if ever Hadi becomes PM, America would open up a “compound” here in Malaysia and support their friends in the oil production business then women like Nurrul Izzah would be silenced behind her veil comforted with the knowledge that Western arms companies would supply the Mullahs with everything they need to secure the country.

    Who knows, maybe even the United Kingdom may get into the act now that they are cutting spending of their military but bolstering their trade with suspect regimes. Why can’t you stupid people realize that if only the American Right were in control the world would be a safer and just place.

    Maybe Harry is right. Perhaps a some people need to be trained like dogs, and you can bet your last ringgit that ideas like these –

    The world would be better-served if we stick to these time-tested principles:
    1) Liberty
    2) In God/Truth we trust
    3) Of many, one, within a nation boundary.

    – would not be part of the training.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.