Can Anwar Ibrahim-led Malaysia’s Opposition actually win May 5 Elections?


May 1, 2013

Can Anwar Ibrahim-led Malaysia’s Opposition actually win May 5 Elections?

April 30, 2013

by Kevin Lees

anwar

In 2008, Malaysia’s opposition surprised the world when it denied the ruling government a two-thirds majority for the first time since Malaysian independence in 1957, thereby depriving it of the ability to amend the country’s constitution with unilateral prerogative.malaysia flag

With Malaysians headed to the polls on Sunday, however, there’s no doubt that the opposition will make further inroads in what promises to be the country’s closest-ever election.

But with a relatively popular Prime Minister in Najib Razak, robust growth and some signs of a growing crackdown on corruption and liberalization of freedom, it’s not at all clear that Malaysia will mark a full rupture from the ruling party.  Even if it does so, the likely Prime Minister in the event of an Opposition win, Anwar Ibrahim, is the former heir apparent to longtime Malaysian leader Mahathir Mohamad, who led the country from 1981 to 2003.

While the campaign has been for over a year quite electric, it’s not clear just how much policy would change if either candidate wins, though the Opposition has argued that it would tackle corruption and shred Najib’s flagship New Economic Model, unveiled in 2010 as a plan to double Malaysian per capita income from $7,500 to $15,000 by 2020 in favor of a more egalitarian policy to achieve ever greater levels of economic development.

Political life in post-Mahathir Malaysia has been relatively more exciting than during his 22 years in office, which is most notable for Malaysia’s transformation from a relatively rural backwater into a high-growth economic powerhouse in southeast Asia.  Mahathir’s reforms included massive privatization and liberalization in the 1980s that unlocked decades of climbing living standards, despite the southeast Asian crisis of the late 1990s that sent the Malaysian ringgit plunging and notwithstanding affirmative action efforts to the benefit the bumiputera, the ethnic Malay majority, in light of the continued dominance of ethnic Chinese in the Malaysian economy.

Dr Mahathir-nstMahathir’s rule also featured some autocratic aspects, chiefly a deficit of press freedom, an infamous ‘Internal Security Act’ that allowed for arbitrary detention without trial.  He also effected often abrasive relations with the United States.

When Mahathir stepped aside, his successor, Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, actually improved the governing coalition’s standing in the March 2004 elections, winning nearly 198 out of 222 seats in the lower house of Malaysia’s parliament on behalf of the Barisan Nasional (BN, National Front), the multi-ethnic umbrella group dominated by the United Malays National Organisation (UMNO) and, to a lesser degree, the Malaysian Chinese Association (MCA) and the Malaysian Indian Congress (MIC).

But in the March 2008 elections, Abdullah suffered a stinging defeat to the Pakatan Rakyat (PR, People’s Alliance), largely comprised of three parties:

  • the People’s Justice Party (PKR), a centrist party formed in 1999 that has campaigned against corruption and in favor of greater equality within the Malaysian economy (and not just UMNO supporters);
  • the Democratic Action Party (DAP), formed in the 1960s as a leftist secular opposition party that receives much of its support from ethnic Chinese in urban Malaysia; and
  • the Pan-Islamic Malaysian Party (PAS), an Islamic democratic party that predates independence, though it remains one of the world’s most moderate proponents of Islamic democracy, in accordance with the mellow nature of the majority of Malaysia’s Muslims.

Malaysia is a multi-religious, multi-ethnic state — about 60% of its population practices Islam, while 20% practices Buddhism, with smaller minorities practicing Christianity and Hinduism.  Ethnic Malays account for about 60% of Malaysia’s population, though ethnic Chinese account for nearly 23% and ethnic Indians account for around 7%.  Despite racial and ethnic tensions in the past — Singapore, where ethnic Chinese comprise nearly 75% of the population, withdrew from the Malaysian federation in 1965 over irreconcilable difference over ethnicity.

Anwar’s background in Malaysian public life is long and complicated.He was widely credited with smart growth policies as Malaysia’s Finance Minister from 1991 to 1998 under Mahathir, who also elevated Anwar to Deputy Prime Minister.

The two fell out over the Malaysian economy during the Asian financial crisis that took root in 1998, and Mahathir rapidly dispatched Anwar to prison on what are widely believed to be politically fabricated charges of corruption.  A second conviction for sodomy followed, and though it was subsequently reversed and Anwar left prison in 2004, he was arrested again on sodomy charges in 2008 that were finally dismissed only last year.

His wife, Wan Azizah Wan Ismail, led the 2008 campaign in his stead, and as the leader of Malaysia’s opposition forces in 2013, he’s called for a more independent media and judiciary, as well as an end to the cozy economic rewards for members of Malaysia’s longtime ruling elite.

The opposition Pakatan Rakyat coalition currently controls 77 of the 222 seats in the Dewan Rakyat (House of Representatives), Malaysia’s lower house, in contrast to the 135 currently held by the majority Barisan Nasional coalition.  Members of the Dewan Rakyat are elected in single-member constituencies on a simple first-past-the-post basis.

Although Anwar is expected to narrow the gap further, it’s not certain if Pakatan Rakyat can pull off enough of an upset to win even more seats than Barisan Nasional.  The opposition is also hoping to expand its control at the state level — it currently controls four of 13 state governments in Kelantan, Kedah, Penang and Selangor, all relatively urban states on peninsular Malaysia (as opposed to Sabah and Sarawak, the two states that comprise east Malaysia on the island of Borneo that’s shared also by Indonesia and by the tiny nation of Brunei).

najib

Counting against the Opposition is the fact that the UMNO remains relatively strong in the rural portions of the country that have a disproportionate voice in Malaysian politics.  Najib (pictured above) himself is a popular official — he’s the son of Malaysia’s second prime minister, Abdul Razak Hussein.

It helps that Najib has, for now, the support of Mahathir, who hastened Abdullah’s resignation and boosted Najib to the premiership as his replacement in the aftermath of the 2008 electoral disaster.  Mahathir continues to condemn his old Deputy Anwar in harsh terms, though the old boss is still making noise about replacing Najib if he doesn’t improve on the coalition’s 2008 result.

It also helps that Malaysia, despite a blip of a contraction in 2009, notched over 7% growth in 2010 and around 5.1% and 5.6% GDP growth in 2011 and 2012, respectively.  Whatever you want to say about the entrenched UMNO interests, it’s never easy to dislodge a government in what amounts to economic boom times.

Moreover, Najib has taken some steps to reduce the impact of policies favoring ethnic Malays and to liberalize freedoms in Malaysia.  He repealed the infamous Internal Security Act in 2012, though critics argue that its replacement, the  Security Offences (Special Measures) Act, is hardly much of an improvement.  His ’1Malaysia’ campaign has effectively blurred the line between government and party promotion, however, and he retains the advantages of incumbency that have kept the UMNO in power for nearly half a century.

All of which means that despite what appears to be yet another landmark election for the Malaysian opposition, Anwar and the Pakatan Rakyat more likely than not face the next five years stuck on the outside looking in.

Kevin Lees

http://suffragio.org/2013/04/30/can-malaysias-opposition-actually-win-sundays-elections/

20 thoughts on “Can Anwar Ibrahim-led Malaysia’s Opposition actually win May 5 Elections?

  1. The writer’s (Kevin Lees) conclusion is that “despite what appears to be yet another landmark election for the Malaysian opposition, Anwar and the Pakatan Rakyat more likely than not face the next five years stuck on the outside looking in.” On what basis has this Washington DC based lawyer come to this conclusion? And do you who have local knowledge of the campaign so far agree with his assessment? Lees sounds like Nile Bowie, that pro-BN independent writer-political analyst.–Din Merican

  2. Dato Din, please reproduce the article written by Dr Chandra Muzaffar entitled “Think and vote wisely” that appeared in the STAR newspaper today May 1, 2013.
    I think all fair-minded person should read this excellent article.
    Regards.
    Estee

  3. BN is going to win through cheating. First, the early postal votes. Now, the delible indelible ink. But God is great, these lies and deceits will be exposed.

  4. He does not even know his facts

    1) Malaysia was no backwater when Mahathir took over but was behind Singapore because it was more proctectionist. Recession forced liberalization ANY Malaysian PM would have done.. Privatization was Reagan-Thatcher-led global phenom and easily adopted by every corrupt crony economic planner.

    2) Political life uninteresting under Mahathir? 3 Deputy PM sacked? Ops Lallang? The going ons in Sabah?

    3) Singapore did not withdrew from Malaysia – IT GOT KICKED OUT..

    4) Anwar and Mahathir did not fell out of economic plan, but rather WHO gets to keep and control the loot.

  5. Sometimes and if not all the times, most of the western written opinions are actually not even suited a dust bin. No doubts that there were countless brilliant scholars and thinkers from west but east had their fare share as well. Just because a writter or so called an ‘experts’ from west published an article about a subject is worth a piece of paper its was written, we, the easterners are much more better than this junkies.

  6. Different writers and analysts come up with different conclusions, some with reasonable basis but others apparently without – still they are free to express their opinions and readers retaining freedom of choice. But I think the guess made by Kevin Lees is correct that the BN will again win the GE13.

  7. BN will only win this GE through massive vote-rigging, phantom voters and cheating…. the people just not with them.

  8. Didi, If GOD is with you who can be against you. God is with Malaysia so logically who can be against Malaysia.

    As the old cinema adverts goes, the next change is “PR to PJ”, can’t wait to see this film.

  9. With the majority of the non-Malays (at least 80%) and 50% of the Malays expected to vote for the opposition, can the remaining 20% of the non-Malay and 50% of the remaining Malay voters return a BN victory for GE 13? No, I don’t think so.

  10. Estee,

    I see that your plea for fair-minded people to read Dr Chandra’s article was granted by Din.

    Interesting isn’t it that nearly all the fair-minded people in Din’s blog was not taken in by Dr Chandra, to put it mildly. It therefore begs the question, why were you persuaded by his article when the others were not? Surely, you must be right?

  11. Dear hak55,

    Where did you get your figures from? A ballpark figure like that is disingenuous. Don’t forget our fellow citizens in East Malaysia or the Bangladeshis, Filipinos and what not, who seem to be playing a spoiler role.

    If PR wins even by a whisker, what we can say is that their total popular vote must exceed >58%, otherwise the other factors will weigh in disproportionately. We can only hope and pray.

  12. Unlike JK expecting trouble, I hope all Malaysians will revert to reasons after this GE13 and accept the results irrespective of which party wins. On the eve of election day let us not harp on expectation of trouble as if willing it to occur but to control our emotion instead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.