Karim Raslan’s Positive Spin: Towards a Brave New Malaysia


September 21, 2011

Towards a brave new Malaysia

By Karim Raslan-09-20-11
newsdesk@thestar.com.my

Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak may have appropriated core Pakatan Rakyat issues with his September 15 civil liberties announcements, but more crucial is whether Malaysians are ready to face up to the challenges.PRIME Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak surprised Malaysia on September 15. In one fell swoop, he appears to have turned the civil liberties agenda into a Barisan Na­­sional initiative.Announcing plans to abolish and/or amend the Internal Security Act (ISA), the Printing Presses and Publications Act (PPPA) as well as other laws, Najib has cleverly appropriated core Pakatan Rakyat issues.

In doing so, he has also demonstrated that UMNO is capable of renewal. Indeed, the party of Merdeka – as I’ve always argued – is infinitely more diverse than many realise or wish to acknowledge. After all, it ranges from figures such as Deputy Minister of Higher Education Datuk Saifuddin Abdullah at the moderate end of the spectrum to hardliners such as Deputy Education Minister Dr Puad Zarkashi.

Moreover, in times of crisis, the party has the ability to adapt, discarding outdated thinking quickly and effectively. In this respect, its internal discipline and sense of common purpose allows for sudden shifts in direction by its leaders.

Of course, the same leaders then have to be able to win elections with these new policy initiatives – and win big at that. Losing is not an option. It’s also important to bear in mind that UMNO members possess a strong sense of self-preservation. Party members are not lemmings leaping to their doom.

On the face of it, the PM’s bold move returns UMNO to the moderate centre-ground. This is a major relief. Nonetheless, there’s a lot of work left to be done and the PM’s credibility will be utterly destroyed if he fails to make good on the September 15 announcements.

For a start, Najib will have to work hard and fast to repeal and replace these laws. He must prove that he can walk the talk. He must also head off the sceptics within UMNO’s right wing. So, while the move is to be applauded, ordinary Malaysians need to keep lobbying and pushing for change. We cannot let up or Barisan will revert to inertia.

As a writer, however, I’m most concerned with what will happen to the media. A functioning democracy needs a free and independent press and the PPPA has been a long-term stumbling block to both.

First off, I, along with most Malaysians, want more details. I totally disagree with the need for newspaper licences. The very concept is wrong-headed. Second, access to and ownership of the media are also critical. We need all sides of the political debate (Barisan and Pakatan) to be given fair and equal coverage.

Malaysians can only make in­­formed decisions about who to vote for if they’re properly informed.It’s worth bearing in mind that blanket media coverage of BN leaders has been a major turn-off. Whoever thought we needed to watch the PM wishing the country Selamat Hari Raya again and again was wrong. With the media, less is more, especially when you have nothing to say.

The current order also makes BN politicians lazy and high-handed when dealing with journalists and editors. But a freeing up of the media will force BN cadres to change – let’s call it political Darwinism.

The Singapore Government is also experimenting with liberalisation. During its recent general election, Singapore’s ruling PAP allowed its press some latitude in their coverage of the opposition. While the opposition made substantial gains, the ruling party still won because ordinary Singaporeans saw the candidates for what they were and still felt safer with the PAP.

There’s no reason to assume why the same couldn’t happen here, all the more so if the Prime Minister maintains his humility and candour.

At this stage, I must add that I would personally like to see Najib go head-to-head with Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim in a live, no holds barred debate during the next polls. Such a debate would give Malaysians the chance to see who has a better vision for the country. Besides, UMNO leaders really need to overcome their pathological fear of Anwar’s supposed superhuman rhetorical skills.

The man is not invincible. Then Information Minister Datuk Seri Ahmad Shabery Cheek faced him back in 2008 and came out of the encounter very creditably.

Umno politicians also have to realise that constant communication and media coverage is the order of the day. Those who are not up to the exposure and pressure should be dropped – Barisan is better off without them. Certainly, if I had my way I’d dump over 80% of the present Cabinet. Most are ill-equipped for present-day challenges.

Also, reporters are stakeholders to be engaged, not hirelings to be ordered about. Treat them with respect and the returns will be considerable. Remember that the media, however tetchy and irritating, is the voice of the people.

At the same time, Malaysia’s mainstream media will now have to up its game. With Najib’s reforms, there’ll no longer be any excuse to not provide the critical news, investigative reporting and analysis that Malaysians crave.

We are tasked to serve the people and not our erstwhile political masters. Najib has opened the door to a new world. We know most of his Barisan Nasional colleagues are ill-prepared. The tougher question is this: are we – the Malaysian people – ready for what’s to come?

17 thoughts on “Karim Raslan’s Positive Spin: Towards a Brave New Malaysia

  1. Political Darwinism?
    What on earth is that! You mean all this while we are/were led by the Doctrine of Political Moronism? Heresy, I tell you! Brave new world? I’m ready – mine hero is John the Savage (A. Huxley). Forgive my schizophrenia. Blame it on Dato’, for this series of drivel..

  2. Dear CLF,

    Brave new world ?

    “We” as in humanity, are entering a new world order for sure but I doubt that it is one that is more humane.

    Your schizophrenia is forgiven as I suspect there is reason behind the madness ? 🙂 Socialism has been pushed against the proverbial brick wall and capitalism has been butchered by the oligarchs. There is a gigantic social storm brewing and when it comes, the world denizens will wrestle the reins of governments back from the money lenders and their political puppets and create governments with elected representatives that are truly by the choice of people and for the interests of the people !

    It is just a matter of time before the common people go beramok !

  3. Karim Raslan just woke up from his sleep when the rest of us had already wised up to the fraudulent take of Najib on the ISA issue.

    Najib is an irresponsible national leader, He does not take ownership or fails to show that he owns what he says in public.

    After his Malaysia speech on the ISA and the emergency laws, Najib went into hiding on the issue and asked his half-clever cousin and the semi-bald 2007 Village Idiot to talk on the ISA issue. Instead of defending Najib’s speech , they engaged in a one-upmanship with Malaysians and in effect, parroting the lines of Perkasa’s Ibrahim Ali.

    The moral of the story: Never trust UMNO leaders when they say they want to undertake reforms. It is all bullshit talk. They never walk their talk. When the election is over, they go back on their promises.

    Karim Raslan is a wishy-washy commentator, still having his heads in the cloud writing about useless feel-good issues of little relevance to realpolitik of Malaysia. He should stick to writing to inconsequential Asian issues where nobody gives TWO hoots about them.

  4. UMNO and Najib are just puffing hot air.

    If they are really serious about political renewal or Malaysia’s well-being, Najib would have deal with the iissue of corruption in UMNO and Barisan Nasional upfront. But then that means he would have to subject himself to investigation.

    Asking to abolish these civil laws … he may be paving for the day when he loses power and risk being arrested under these laws for treason and sedition. Take for example the citizenship for votes that is openly happening now … is Najib and UMNO totally ignorant anout this? I doubt so. Isn’t that treason and something that the ISA is supposed to be for?

  5. If all you may recall, prior to the 2008 General Elections, Karim was predicting big wins for BN.
    His pro-BN writing stance changed only after the results of the elections were announced.
    He is a poor soothsayer but even an unconvincing post-event commentator.

  6. Yeah, we are heading for a braver new Malaysia alright. Najib is mulling about including hefty bonuses in the 2012 budget for the 1.3 million civil servants. Problem is, a week or two ago he claimed that there are only 1.2 million taxpaying citizens. I might be dumb in economics but wouldn’t that give us problem in the long run? Are we following Greece’s footsteps in terms of a bloating government?

  7. Can anyone, any one in M’sia pls stop talking and start doing, the right thing.-Kathy

    Many have done it and many have been guest of His Majesty Government.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.