Doctor on the Run: Fabricate Evidence or Else?


Monday, July 28, 2008

The doctor’s report says it very clearly. Saiful was never sodomised, either by Anwar or anyone else. Why is the government still pursuing the case against Anwar? And why are they looking for the doctor who has now gone underground with his whole family?

NO HOLDS BARRED

Raja Petra Kamarudin

On July 21, 2008, I published an article in this same column called HOW, YET AGAIN, THEY ARE TRYING TO FABRICATE EVIDENCE AGAINST ANWAR. (Read the article here ).

In that article I mentioned as follows:

You see, they asked a certain doctor from a certain hospital to conduct an examination on Saiful. The doctor did so and he came out with a report that said there is no evidence Anwar had ever penetrated or sodomised the young man. The police then picked up the doctor and detained him for three days. As much as they tried to force him to change his report to implicate Anwar he refused to do so.

Until today, the doctor stands by his report that there is no evidence Anwar had sodomised Saiful. He knows he is going to be made to pay for this but he doesn’t care. He is not going to change his report and say that Anwar sodomised Saiful whatever they do to him. Exasperated, the police had to release Anwar on personal bond or police bail. The doctor refuses to doctor his report and neither does Anwar want to volunteer his new specimen.

Well, that doctor’s name is Dr Mohamed Osman Abdul Hamid from the Hospital Pusrawi and he has now taken his entire family and has gone into hiding because the police are looking for him and they want him to change his medical report.

At 2.00pm on June 28, 2008, Mohd Saiful Bukhari Bin Azlan went to see Dr Mohamed Osman to complain about a pain he is suffering in his anus. Saiful told the doctor that he had been assaulted by ‘a very important person’ — meaning, of course, sodomised by Anwar Ibrahim.

Dr Mohamed Osman examined Saiful but found no evidence that he had been sodomised, either by Anwar Ibrahim or anyone else for that matter. The doctor’s report (which can be viewed below) says that there is zero (0) skin tearing, zero (0) active bleeding, zero (0) traces of pus, etc., which basically means he can’t be suffering from a pain in the anus as what he alleges.

The doctor’s diagnosis is that he rules out or TRO (to rule out) assault (sodomised). In short: Mohd Saiful Bukhari Bin Azlan is not suffering any pain in the anus and neither was he assaulted or sodomised in the anus.

Saiful then said he would like to make a police report so Dr Mohamed Osman suggested he go for a second medical examination at a government hospital. Saiful did so and the doctor at the government hospital also came out with the same diagnosis. Nevertheless, Saiful still made his police report at the pondok police in the hospital.

In spite of the doctors all confirming that Saiful was never sodomised, the police still pursued the case. Anwar Ibrahim was subsequently arrested by about 20 SWAT members in Balaclavas and armed to the teeth in a dramatic movie-style action-packed drama in front of his house after he had confirmed he would be reporting to the police station at 2.00pm as required.

The police detained Anwar in the lockup until the next morning and even brought him to the hospital for examination and to try to obtain his specimen for what the police say are for purposes of doing a DNA profile. The fact that the police already have Anwar’s DNA profile from 1998, plus the doctors from both hospitals confirm that Saiful was never sodomised, did not seem to matter.

Clearly the government is attempting to fabricate evidence against Anwar and is trying to indict him on trumped-up charges of sodomy. And who but the slime-ball AG and scumbag IGP, the same two players in the 1998 episode, can be behind this latest travesty of justice.

The doctor’s report says it very clearly. Saiful was never sodomised, either by Anwar or anyone else. Why is the government still pursuing the case against Anwar? And why are they looking for the doctor who has now gone underground with his whole family?

Civil society movements, NGOs and the Malaysian Bar Council must not remain silent. The police have already detained the doctor for three days but he still refuses to doctor his medical report. Anwar did not sodomise Saiful and the doctor’s report says it very clearly. And the police also have a copy of this same report that I have published below so they know what I know. And now Malaysians also already know what I and the police know — that Saiful was never sodomised by anyone.

ADDENDUMS

Pusrawi Medical Report

Pusrawi Medical Report

Download annotated version

40 thoughts on “Doctor on the Run: Fabricate Evidence or Else?

  1. I urge that the doctor and his family be protected for upholding the truth. People like this should not be punished for the truth that they seek to uphold… and we should emulate the bravery of these people by never bowing to the demands of these corrupt individuals.

  2. Someone might want to look into starting a political safe house to shelter those who gets into trouble for speaking the truth.

    Wonder what the police will say about this?

  3. “..Saiful did so and the doctor at the government hospital also came out with the same diagnosis.”

    Anyone have a copy of the govt hospital doctor’s report?

    By the look of things, someone’s butt is gonna be blown off – but dont know who.

  4. He he he, If the first medical which was shown are true, then where and when actually did the sodomy took place????? If police are adamant that it happened, why are all these evidence showing otherwise. Are the police trying to create evidence to implicate Anwar???? If yes then who is/are behind this devilish scheme?

  5. ibat,

    It’s obvious, call him – advisor, plotter, conspirator, a mischief maker or assassin!
    He’s the real threat to national security! The rule of law must apply and seen to function in this country and the whole world is watching.

    Everything’s out in the open, what’s next? What are they waiting for? Are they going to arrest him balaclava-style?

  6. Jong,

    Since this doc’s report is now in the open, would we be wrong to expect a worldwide search for Dr Mohamed Osman Abdul Hamid by PDRM? Shouldn’t all the menteris now come out and say he should not have any fear?

  7. Jebatmust die,

    You are simply pathetic and you are one of those RPK calls “Kaaba Muslims”. They sin, drink, fornicate and slander others simply because of the threat they feel to their empires. Hogwash. Anyway , the Hospital doesn’t answer your calls regarding a Dr. You have got to visit and then they will see what are your ailments. They don’t explain which Dr and from when and where did join their Hospital and what he/she does.

    There is a PUSRWAWI Dr who shed light on what an examination entails and she personally wrote to Malaysiakini and lashed at the dubious ways certain nefarious and hateful elements want things to be done. Knowing that you belong to that Stone Age despicable horde, read what she wrote here:

    http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/86602

  8. I wonder if they realise that foreign diplomates/investors are watching the situation, their transparency, integrity and credibility is at stake.

  9. Jebatmust die,

    While it is not the golden rule to believe everything RPK throws at us, your asking the hospital about the doc drew blank perhaps because the hospital already knew about the whole thing. It PROBABLY erase any connection with the missing doc for obvious reason – it did not want to be dragged in. I may be wrong. I may not believe RPK but I do not think RPK is stupid, do you?

  10. Jebatmustdie,

    Yes you are pathetic as Abdul said. If you read Malaysiakini you will learn that the said doctor is on leave due to the tremendous pressure this episode is having on him. In malay your attitude is called “Bodoh Sombong”

  11. PM Badawi, what are you waiting for. The evidence have been presented to you. The Medical report by the doctor confirmed Shitful was not done in. Summon Syed Alblur and both of you should make a Press Statement wrapping up this Sodomy case while at the same time go after Shitful and arrest him for making false police report. Interrogate him and make him sign a SD identifying and implicating the person (s) behind (no pun intended) all this shameful conspiracy. It’s the least that you as PM should do.

    IF YOU CANNOT, UNABLE OR UNWILLING THEN RESIGN AND TAKE YOUR WHOLE CABINET WITH YOU.

  12. Well…. do we have to listen to the Police Director Of Criminal Investigation after this….??

    Bangsaaarrtttt………

  13. Cis Jebat must die
    You challenging the anak Raja Bugis? I suggest you just crawl back into your hole and just die. Raja Petra is not an average Joe and I don’t think you will ever measure up to him in all aspect, courage, integrity and honesty.
    The hospital is a business and any negative publicity will result in the Ministry of Health conduct a raid and will find reasons to close the hospital The poor doctor being an honest guy now have to hide, not from tghe crooks but from the police who will act like KGB to make him change his medical report.
    Why is it so hard for you to understand that these people are sacrificing their lives and their families to uphold justice. It’s easy for you to make such comments under guise. Put yourself in their shoes?
    Shrek shivering in pants already 10-4

  14. Two scenarios:

    1. This sodomy conspiracy was a pure Najis deal, without Bodohwi’s knowing or blessing; designed to bring down DSAI yet again. Quite possibly, the old dog Mahathir gave the blessing, especially so when he quickly came to the ‘conclusion’ that it MUST be true, since it ‘happened’ during his reign. All this in the same self-delusion that we Malaysians are really that stupid. Of course, the assumption that the monkey throne already belongs to Najis, come June 2010. So, in the head of Najis, Anwar is the ONLY threat to his right to ascend the monkey throne, nevermind that this is the last thing the Bodohwi-SIL tag team wants for this clown. Also, don’t forget Ku Li and Muhiyidin too want the crown. You see, to UMNO, this crown on the monkey throne belongs to them, that Malaysia is at their disposal to do what they want. In that case, this will be another way grip on the balls of Najis added to the others, ie relating to the murder of a certain Mongolian beauty. The timeline for the ascension may now be moved further, say by a year or two.

    OR

    2. This scheme was designed with collaboration with both these monkeys, supported by their own ‘clever monkeys’ ie the SIL and the old man. Both are definitely shitting brick-loads looking at the groundswell of support Anwar has been able to garner – the Indians have all abandoned MIC and the Chinese are totally pissed off with UMNO and the ‘ketuanan melayu’ bullshit and consider MCA nothing but a bunch of running dogs – I dare say that come GE13, MCA and Gerakan will be completely wiped out. The recent nation-wide TV debate (the monkeys must be banging their balls for allowing this to happen) which saw Anwar completely shattering the foam-in-the-mouth little monkey’s pathetic attempt to justify fuel price increase (in fact, what attempt?), didn’t help much to the sinking ship of UMNO. And now, we have the monkeys fully utilising the MSM machinery to split the PR apart (personally, I am furious as hell with PAS for the lust of power – good riddance to bad rubbish if they wish to fcuk with monkeys).
    In this case, you can wait until the cows come home, for Bodohwi to take any action against Najis.

  15. jebatmustdie ,
    “… even their website does not list this doctor’s”
    name.”

    The web site says, “Senarai Pakar Perubatan” which means List of Medical Specialists.

    The doctor in question is surely not a specialist. Such elementary anal examination are always done by MOs or junior doctors.

  16. but the latest update of the pusrawi website was 16 Jun 2008. How come someone would erase the Dr’s name before the allegation?

  17. The fact that there is no evidence, ie no bleeding etc, does not mean that the event did not occur. The ‘special one’ (not refering to anyone specific here) simply need to use a lubricant to avoid any injury to the ‘innocent one’. There is a possibility.

    I don’t see any real solid evidence here.
    Btw, why did PUSRAWI decides that Mr Saiful should see a MO, instead of a specialist, Urologist to be exact . Is the MO the right person to asses this case. Should it not be done by a urologist. Shouldn’t the MO instead recommend that Saiful be referred to a urologist. Someone rape this poor b*st*rd, and instead of getting second opinion, ie thru an actual specialist, the MO send him packing. What kinda doctor is he.

    Is this medical report enough to say that Saiful was not sodomize (by whomever), honestly i don’t think so.

  18. hamba,
    The doctor that checked Saiful is not a specialist, he is an MO as mentioned by Mr Smith. His name will not appear on the list of specialist. What you see on the website is a list of specialist.

    Please read Din Merican’s later posting on similar topic as posted in Malaysiakini.

  19. eh? Why suddenly I’m labelled this and that? U people do not even know me. I just called the hospital, and asked them to direct me to the said doctor.

    is it not wrong to get 1st hand information?

    And the nurses there stated the said doctor do not exist. Hence, that’s what I tried to say in my first comment.

    Should i not have an opinion also?

    Why the sudden hostility from all of you?

    Regardless he is an MO or not, the nurses there (I spoke to 3 nurses) should know the man right?

    Anyway, it’s a mistake to give comments here. I didn’t know this website do not accept any other views other than it’s owner.

    I apologise and thank you for the opportunity.

  20. ok I got the info

    NAME : THAN AUNG @ MOHAMED OSMAN HAMID
    QUALIFICATION : MBBS
    UNDERGRADUATE OF : UNIVERSITY OF RANGOON-RANGOON MEDICAL COLLEGE

    APC NO: 19396

    Year: 2008

    Hospital Pusrawi s/b
    lot 149, jalan tun razak
    50400 kuala lumpur
    WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN KUALA LUMPUR

  21. Dude Cerosky,
    You really have to be an idiot (or a cybertrooper or both) to continue to swallow this big fat lie bait, hook and sinker! Look what you are saying – you are now teaching us how this butt-hole screwing is done. In your little brain, you have condemned Anwar guilty of sodomising Saiful just because you have been told so, and any evidence proving otherwise must be fabricated, otherwise your little brain will simply reject it.

  22. Dear Barry,

    Please highlight , where the f*** did i say Anwar is guilty of sodomizing Saiful.

    I’m simply stating what is fact, and what is not. Did i say i believe the allegation is true, where did i say that. Tell me. What’s wrong with you people. Read carefully what i said.

    I’m just saying the evidence that claim Saiful was not sodomize is not strong enough. That’s it.
    Same can be said also about evidence that claim Anwar sodomize Saiful, but right now we are not discussing about them.

    Get that registered in your so called small bodypart call brain.

  23. Dude Cerosky,
    Read your previous post line by line, carefully. You were clearly implying that Saiful was indeed sodomised (last line), that this new documentary evidence as produced has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that this little monkey asshole was NOT sodomised.

  24. Dear Barry,

    You think the two NOT statement compliment each other and therefore make a TRUE statement.
    Is this your logic? Ha ha, it’s quite funny,
    obviously you don’t even understand what i’m saying.

    It’s ok. Some simple mind can not simply think.

  25. “Why is the government still pursuing the case against Anwar? And why are they looking for the doctor who has now gone underground with his whole family?”

    What has Malaysia become these days?

    At the height of apostasy cases like Moorthy others saw us as a nation of body snatchers. Before that at the height of Anwar’s trial in 1999, we were seen as a nation of people with Victorian values fixated on unnatural sex when the rest of the world cannot be sure if there is anything like natural sex. In a world when you could have children without having sex, when other women could give birth to your children, when you do not have to be of the opposite sex to marry, naturally there is nothing natural.

    While in other legal jurisdictions prosecutors and defense counsel cooperate to prevent a possible miscarriage of justice, our prosecutor and defense counsel and judge despite being part of the adversarial system, are colluding with one another to ensure a miscarriage of justice.

    Our justice system is not what it used to be; we have become a nation of people who like to declare. We not only like to declare that we have nothing to declare every time we pass customs, but we also declare what we do not know – the innocence and guilt of others.

    Witnesses are people with direct personal knowledge of events that courts would need to call for help in the process of determining the guilt or otherwise of those accused. Our courts do not call witnesses with direct personal knowledge of the events but call those who could only quote what others have had to say. Those with direct personal knowledge of the events have instead been ‘ encouraged’ to ‘seek the security’ of foreign jurisdictions so that they could not be extradited back.

    We are really messed up.

  26. “However, is the medical report by the missing doc as published now authentic? Get that answered ..”

    If the hospital authorities are conducting their internal investigation into how the medical report was leaked, it is safe to assume for now that it is authentic.

    The problem is the hearsay nature of this type of evidence.

    We do not want to admit this report merely to show how beautiful the handwriting of the doctor is or how efficiently he carried out his duties as a doctor. It is an out of court statement and we want to admit it into evidence to show the truth of its contents. That is hearsay and the law of evidence prohibits the use of the report in that way. The only way is to call the maker of the statement as a witness, in which event it is his testimony that is the evidence and not his report.

    So we are back to square one. Where is the maker? He is not deceased. If he is shown to be deceased then it could be admitted into evidence. The only issue then would be the weight of the evidence – in the absence of a jury trial, the question of weight of the evidence is for the judge to decide. Augustine Paul, where are you??

    Since the maker of the report is not deceased, he would have to be found and a subpoena served personally on him – a process which could take forever. The cows will not be allowed to come home!

    In the meantime a dark cloud will hover over Anwar’s head wherever he goes. A dark cloud is no substitute for a halo.

  27. but the name Than Aung also was not in the hospital list?

    and from where did hamba get the info? thank you.

  28. Nah, just another pathetic patchwork trying to cover up for their political masters!

    The CEO and his staff, medical or otherwise better be reminded that a lie is a lie and they must take full responsibility if this case goes to court.

  29. Judging from Hospital Pusrawi’s response, it now confirms the ‘Medical Report’, “Medical Record’ or ‘Medical Note’, whatever you call it is genuine.

    Expecting more patchwork coming. The more they try to cover the more they fumble!

  30. HakCipta © 2005-2006 Hospital Pusrawi. Semua HakCipta Terpelihara.

    {Kemaskini Terakhir : 16 Jun 2008}

    HOSPITAL PUSRAWI SDN. BHD. Lot 149, Jalan Tun Razak, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
    Tel +(603)2687-5000. Fax +(603)2687-5001. info@pusrawi.com.my

  31. OK. Now we have an authentic medical record or report by a doctor who cannot be contacted despite the best of effort. We are not much closer to the truth!

  32. Actually, what’s happening to judicial independence and unbiased police investigation? Its a far cry from the ultimate freedom as embedded in the country’s constitution. It seems that other than the monarch, those who are at the top of power are also above the law and they can also use other government machinery to orchestrate their objective to hold to power. Come on Malaysian, its not time for think and rethink. Its time to react to uphold justice and put the constitution back to where it belongs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.