Din Merican: the Malaysian DJ Blogger
The desire to write grows with writing–Desiderius Erasmus Roterodamus

Message to All Malays who still live the Past

March 31, 2010

PERKASA: Have lunatics taken over?

by Mariam Mokhtar (March 30, 2010)

When one reads about an organisation led by an insecure, attention seeking leader, who revels in obfuscating remarks to “defend Islam, the special rights of Malays and bumiputeras”, it does seem that the lunatics have taken over the asylum.

So, am I alone in thinking that Malays should debunk Ketuanan Melayu (Malay supremacy)? When challenging small, hate-filled groups we must be aware of the risks in talking up the threat they pose.

perkasa publicationThey may hope we would demonstrate or march to the police station and make reports (the police have better things to do) and give the group added gravitas.

Probably the more invectives that are hurled in retaliation, the happier they would be. No, we are not a hysterical lot. Clamours for Ketuanan Melayu are an insult to me and right-minded Malays.

Malays today are knowledgable. Extremist views on race and religion are not our vision of Malaysia. We aim for solidarity by encouraging participation from all sections of society for a truly democratic nation.

Confident Malays are not threatened by other races. Nor do they feel inferior or undermined. They are not spiritually bankrupt and do not get confused when non-Muslims use words like Allah.

Too few benefit

The NEP made a few Malay millionaires into billionaires. It excluded the Malay majority and hence failed spectacularly in its objectives. The government must be more creative in helping Malays attain success. Why stick with a recipe for failure?

Last week’s histrionics demonstrate that you can take the boy out of the kampong but you cannot take the kampong out of the boy. Fortunately, not all Malays live under their tempurung (coconut shell). We don’t need men who profess to be leaders by espousing Ketuanan Melayu but in reality are just sabre-rattlers.

perkasa first agm 270310 bannerMalaysians are aware of their surroundings – abuses of power, select Malays selfishly milking the NEP, endemic corruption, public institutions compromising their neutrality by becoming political stooges, no accountability in government bodies and politicians.

There are many disadvantaged people in Malaysia. Our urban and rural folk lead parallel lives, with little overlap. Our society consists of the ‘haves’ and the ‘have-nots’. Racism, sexism and ageism are rife. It is little wonder there is a rise in cynicism. It is amusing to see the ’1Malaysia’ concept in a mess because of these.

We are a young nation, and we attained independence through the collective effort of the peoples of Malaya:  the Ordinary Malayans – rubber tappers, tin coolies, jungle clearers, road builders, railway workers, teachers, policemen, port labourers.

They were Malays, Chinese, Indians, Eurasians, Orang Asli. Some made the ultimate sacrifice in the name of independence. Must we now forget their contributions and treat their children and grandchildren not as true Malaysians, but merely as immigrants? Are we not indebted to them?

My great-grandfather was a rubber-tapper and he encouraged his son (my grandfather) to study and lift them out of poverty. At night, he studied by the light of a kerosene lamp. During the day, he escaped being called out to play by the other boys, by hiding and reading in the middle of a patch of long grass.

The daily journey to secondary school in Ipoh was by train and on foot. He then entered the Malayan Civil Service (MCS), worked his way up and was sent to England for various courses and tests. He grabbed every opportunity and was a success.

He worked in the towns and villages throughout Malaya, but complained that the Malay youth then were indisciplined, were bad at time-keeping and had an attitude problem. Many suffered from kais pagi, makan pagi (living from hand-to-mouth) and lacked motivation to work. The majority considered the bounties from the fruit trees or rivers sufficient for their daily needs.

This lack of incentive is deeply entrenched and will remain entrenched unless there is a brutal effort to exorcise it from the Malay psyche. We must give Malays a way out of poverty and halt their dependence on the NEP. The challenge is for them to break out of the spiral of underachievement and low expectation.

A crutch, not a panacea

The NEP, or its reincarnation, will not help the Malays or Malaysia. Instead of making Malays more competitive, it will make them more reliant on false hopes. It will make them idle and addicted to being the master, the supreme race, with little effort involved. It is a destructive ideology. It destroys their character and robs them of an identity. It is an admission of weakness. It relieves them of pride and dignity.

The Malays have had large amounts of money spent on them. No amount of money will elevate them unless it is put to good use to improve themselves. The desire to improve must come from within. They must understand that ambition and aspiration entails hard work and perseverance.

Malays have a strong cultural identity and family values but the NEP has helped to  institutionalize underachievement. So how can we offer security to our children if our adults lack ambition?

perkasa first agm 270310 bigger kerisEducation and a strong stable family life must be foremost in policy changes to make a difference. But politicians have messed up our education system. Government must create opportunities. We need investments, both locally and from abroad, but Malaysia’s negative image precludes that.

Those who champion Ketuanan Melayu should concentrate on the Malay community and seek answers for the following:- Malays lacking aspiration; Malay girls outperforming boys; Malay men abrogating responsibilities towards their family, spending money on successively younger wives, leaving families severely disadvantaged; high divorce rates in Malay marriages;

Most drug addicts and HIV/AIDS sufferers are Malays; abandoned babies are primarily Malays; incest, rape and sexual crimes are committed mainly by Malays. Why not sort out your priorities, clean up your own house first and stop pointing fingers?

Sadly, few Malays are willing to admit the faults within them but would rather lay the blame on other races. And please stop brandishing the keris about. They are revered items, as any good Malay knows, and should never be used in a cheap publicity gimmick.

13 Responses to “Message to All Malays who still live the Past”

  1. NEP, actually only help priviledged Umno Malays and Umno pseudo Malays to become rich or filthy rich so that they can take their ill gotten gains and keep in foreign accounts. As for the other 90 % of the genuine Malays in the Kampung, they have become scapegoats to continue this robber policy.

  2. “Probably the more invectives that are hurled in retaliation, the happier they would be. No, we are not a hysterical lot. Clamours for Ketuanan Melayu are an insult to me and right-minded Malays.”

    Right-minded?? Right thinking, you mean. Or like minded?

  3. “It relieves them of pride and dignity.”

    It robs them of their pride in their own achievements. Yes. As when others attribute your success to the discriminatory practices epitomized by the NEP or/and NEP-like policies

  4. QUOTE OF THE WEEK:

    “How can I say I’m Malaysian first and Malay second? All the Malays will shun me… and it’s not proper.”
    - Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin

    Click here to read more on above.

  5. The picture of abuse, misuse, and of the corrupting influence of unbridled power in the hands of the few who are politically connected, would be clearer once the non-Malays and non-Muslims through the policy of attrition migrate to foreign lands to make their living. Then Malays will get to see the NEP or NEP-like policies for what they really are. A policy of discrimination that benefit the politically connected, the rich, the upper middle class Malays, urban dwellers, the bourgeois class more than they do their rural counterparts and the working class Malays who toil daily to bring food to the table. This country would not have developed to where it is today without the blood, sweat and tears of those who work with their hands.

    It is this picture that is being blurred by issues of race, of racism and racial discrimination. The underlying class struggle has all but been ignored. In the end it is a class conflict that transcends racial barriers.

    But right now ordinary folks among the Malays are being manipulated into believing that their woes are race related.

  6. By that statement, Muhyiddin Yassin appears to have his hand on the pulse of the Malays who see their struggle as a Malay struggle i.e. a struggle to survive the flood of more resilient and tenacious immigrants – brought in to work the tin-mines and the plantations and railways by the Brits for the purpose of providing their industries in England with the much needed raw materials and unrelated to the well being of the Malays – a struggle to preserve their Malay and Muslim way of life, their customs, and dare I include the Malay Rulers.

    The problem I have with this picture is that it has been five decades since. Surely the picture has changed.

  7. “Those who champion Ketuanan Melayu should concentrate on the Malay community and seek answers for the following:- Malays lacking aspiration; Malay girls outperforming boys; Malay men abrogating responsibilities towards their family, spending money on successively younger wives, leaving families severely disadvantaged; high divorce rates in Malay marriages;

    Most drug addicts and HIV/AIDS sufferers are Malays; abandoned babies are primarily Malays; incest, rape and sexual crimes are committed mainly by Malays. Why not sort out your priorities, clean up your own house first and stop pointing fingers?

    Sadly, few Malays are willing to admit the faults …”

    ——————————

    How much of these are race related or race based??

    It is to be expected that as we progress as a society, traditional institutions like family, marriage, religion come under tremendous pressure. Traditional values and our belief in traditional institutions are undermined by material progress brought on by modernization seen largely as westernization.

    Over here we see high divorce rates, increasing number of single parents, high drug use especially among teens, teen pregnancies, high crime rate including sexual abuse, more women making it to colleges than guys, husbands defaulting in their alimonies and maintenance. There are of course differences in their incidences among the different races but they have less to do with race and more with economics. You find more of these among the poor and the working class than the middle class.

  8. Dear Mariam Mokhtar,

    Congratulations ! your great grandfather and grandfather had taught you well the values of hard work and discipline. The ” lunatics ” you called in Perkasa ” they can’t see the forest for the trees “. They should take a cue from the Indians and Chinese .

    This is the story, in the 1960′s and 1970′s hundreds of thousand Indian and Chinese boys and girls whose parents could be estate workers, rubber tappers and lorry drivers or hawkers who could not in their wildest dream sent their children oversea for a tertiary education or seek knowledge or skills. There were not much opportunity in higher education either in Malaya or Malaysia.

    Perkasa lunatics, you know what, hundreds of thousand Indian and Chinese boys and girls, left to study or take nursing course in UK, Australia, New Zealand on their own. Most of them had very little financial support from their parents.They made it through hard work.They came back to Malaysia, most of them did well in life, climb the corporate ladder or in the civil service. NEP did not help them. They helped themselves, took jobs weekend and during vacation.

    Most of these girls and boys had done their time for this country, probably now age in their 70′s and 60′s.
    Please lah ! Ahmad Ismail and Ibrahim Ali, stop for a moment , ask yourselves deep in your heart who are you trying to help. Perkasa will not help the young Malays. You gentlemen only want to hang on to Malay rights to enrich yourselves .

    Some top Malay leader should re-examine his belief ” Malay 1st, Malaysian 2nd “. You are not going to change the young Malays, or maybe the intention is to get votes to stay in power. I was one of the thousands who went to UK and made it in UK and came back with 3 qualifications, served in the Corporate sector for 25 years, widely travelled , work had brought me to numerous countries and every year paid thousands of Ringgit taxes.

    I never once in my life complained about lack of opportunities or felt being discriminated. If you had the good things , well and good if you did not have the good things in life worked for it. I was thankful to Almighty God for this blessed country Malaysia. Ahmad Ismail, for your information, my father came to live in Malaya in 1904, at the age of 13 to work as coolie in your state PW. I am 1st generation born and bred in this country. So I have every right to be here and I always called myself MALAYSIAN. I am now in the 60′s and still working and seeking new skills and knowledge on my own.

    Talking about opportunity and NEP support, in my UK days, there were a dozen of Malay students in our college, on MARA or PSD scholarships. The non-Malays got on well with them and had no animosity. We were MALAYSIANS. On one occasion 50 of us, we all got together to put up a show in College for all the ” mat sallehs “. We were proud to be MALAYSIANS , we did good for our country. We did not think of ourselves, Malays, Chinese or Indians .

    Please DPM , bring back this spirit of being MALAYSIAN, not to worry , Malays have nothing to fear or lose. The true spirit of this great nation, strong will help the weak. I loved to work with Malay rural folks. I had done it before, Mr. Ibrahim Ali and Ahmad Ismail.

    It is my one last wish in life before I am call home to the Lord, that I would want to help the some Malays rural folks or young unemployable malay graduates, to achieve PM’s intention to raise our per capital income to US$ 15,000 . I maybe just 1, if I could only make a difference to just 1 person life, I would be happy to leave this world.

  9. It is my one last wish in life before I am call home to the Lord……..” - chinlwu

    Sorry, my friend. You WON’T get your last wish. UMNO/Najib will see to that.

    What you have written here is laudable and certainly, you will get plenty of merit points (ask Tean about it) besides getting kudos from “Your Lord”.

    I can certainly agree with everything you said. To me, they are your prayers which will not be answered in your and my life time as long as UMNO-BN is still in power backed by the newly-UMNO sponsored PERKASA.

    It is a very lonely prayer of yours.

  10. I am a Malay who revel in the past. The past was better than the present and maybe better than the future at the rate Malaysia is being governed. In the past Malays, Chinese, Indians and others live in peace, all in one kampong. In the past the Malays celebrate Chinese New Year and Thaipusam and Deepavali without any inhibition or thoughts that the neighbors are a threat. The Chinese and Indians look forward to Hari Raya wher they will partake in the rendang and ketupat and other delicacies. Thaipusam and Deepavali were celebrated by all not worrying about the religious significance. No one feel threatened of their identity or religious belief.
    The Chinese and Indians made sure the food served to their Malay neighbors were halal. They go out of their way to ensure that. The Malays in turn will inform the Hindus to avoid beef dishes.
    My best friends after 60 years are still the same kids that I grew up with the Lim, Sooriahs, Tan, Chong, Peraba, David, Amrim, Syeds, Kenneth and many more. We plan to have a bash at the end of this year to make a pilgrimage to the kampong that we grew up in, to enjoy maybe for the last time a truly 1 Malaysia.

  11. “The true spirit of this great nation (Malaysia), strong will help the weak.” chinlwu

    In Malaysia the weak are left to help themselves while the strong help themselves to what the weak have helped build. The rest just hit the road.

  12. We still need affirmative action (with obligations from the people who benefit from it). But based on class, not “race”.

    This will benefit the sons and daughters of padi farmers, fishers, rubber tappers, oil palm workers, timber workers, displaced estate residents, indigenous peoples, New Village dwellers and so on.

  13. Hence we call that affirmative action programs over here. It is not meant to benefit any one race. Be that as it may there are white students studying at certain colleges here who have alleged racial discrimination against whites.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 208 other followers